The
Greek language question was a dispute discussing the question whether the language of the Greek people (
DimotikiDimotiki or demotic is the modern vernacular form of the Greek language. The term has been in use since 1818. Dimotiki refers particularly to the form of the language that evolved naturally from ancient Greek, in opposition to the artificially archaic Katharevousa, which was the official standard...
) or a cultivated imitation of Ancient Greek (
KatharevousaKatharevousa , is a form of the Greek language conceived in the early 19th century by Greek intellectual and revolutionary leader Adamantios Korais . A graduate of the University of Montpellier in 1788, Korais spent most of his life as an expatriate in Paris...
) should be the official language of the Greek nation. It was a highly controversial topic in the 19th and 20th centuries and was finally resolved in 1976, when Dimotiki was made the official language. The language phenomenon in question—which occurs elsewhere in the world—is called
diglossiaIn linguistics, diglossia is a situation where a given language community uses two languages or dialects: the first being the community's present day vernacular and the second being either an ancestral version of the same vernacular from centuries earlier , a distinct yet closely related present...
. This term was coined at the turn of the 20th century by
Ioannis PsycharisIoannis Psycharis was a philologist, author and promoter of Demotic Greek...
, a leading participant in the Greek controversy.
Linguistic background of the problem
While Dimotiki was the mother tongue of the Greeks, Katharevousa was an archaic and formal variant that was pronounced like modern Greek, but adopted both lexical and morphological features of ancient Greek that the spoken language had lost over time. Examples of this are:
- Morphological features: Strict Katharevousa still contained the ancient dative case
The dative case is a grammatical case generally used to indicate the noun to whom something is given. For example, in "John gave Mary a book"....
, many participleIn linguistics, a participle is a derivative of a non-finite verb, which can be used in compound tenses or voices, or as a modifier...
s and various additional tenses and conjugational patterns of verbkalleah hit meIn syntax, a verb is a word that usually denotes an action , an occurrence , or a state of being . Depending on the language, a verb may vary in form according to many factors, possibly including its tense, aspect, mood and voice...
s.
- Phonological features: Katharevousa contained various spelling pronunciations which did not fit the Modern Greek phonological system. For example, νδρ (Ancient and Demotic /ndr/, Katharevousa /nðr/), φθ, [α]υθ, [ε]υθ (Ancient /pʰtʰ/, Demotic /ft/, Katharevousa /fθ/ ), σθ, ρθρ.
- Syntactical features: While the language of the people mostly consisted of simple sentences, Katharevousa often applied ancient Greek syntax
In linguistics, syntax is the study of the principles and rules for constructing sentences in natural languages...
to form sentences which would appear as educated speech, that is, long and complex.
- Lexical features: The proponents of the formal language discarded many popular Greek words that the Greek language had obtained from other languages over time, mainly from the Turkish
Turkish is spoken as a first language by over 63 million people worldwide, making it the most commonly spoken of the Turkic languages. Its speakers are located predominantly in Turkey and Cyprus, with smaller groups in Iraq, Greece, Bulgaria, the Republic of Macedonia, Kosovo, Albania and other...
and LatinLatin is an Italic language originally spoken in Latium and Ancient Rome. Through the Roman conquest, Latin spread throughout the Mediterranean and a large part of Europe...
or ItalianItalian is a Romance language spoken by about 60 million people in Italy, and by a total of around 70 million in the world. In Switzerland, Italian is one of four official languages. It is also the official language of San Marino, as well as the primary language of Vatican City...
languages, and either replaced them with ancient Greek words or with neologisms. Similarly, words of ancient Greek origin but by now modern in form were archaicised or replaced by their standard ancient Greek equivalents (like the Ancient Greek ἰχθύς for ψάρι fish or the archaicised εξωκλήσσιον from the modern form ξωκλήσι small chapel).
These differences meant that Katharevousa was only partly intelligible to a Greek without higher education. There was no single Katharevousa. Instead, proponents of the formal language utilized ever-changing variants that never were standardized. These variants were nearly Attic in extreme cases, but they could also be closer to spoken Greek and could be understood by the majority of the people.
Example of the diglossia
For a person who does not speak Greek and whose mother tongue (e.g. English) exhibits no comparable form of diglossia, it is hard to understand the motivation of the Greek language question, as it concerns the coexistence of two—in extreme cases—completely different forms of Greek that greatly exceeds the usual stylistic difference between written and spoken language. It might be compared rather to situations such as a similar language question in medieval
PortugalPortugal , officially the Portuguese Republic , is a country located in southwestern Europe on the Iberian Peninsula. Portugal is the westernmost country of mainland Europe and is bordered by the Atlantic Ocean to the west and south and by Spain to the north and east...
between formal Latin and demotic
PortuguesePortuguese is a Romance language that originated in what is now Galicia and northern Portugal. It is derived from the Latin spoken by the romanized Pre-Roman peoples of the Iberian Peninsula around 2000 years ago...
, which was resolved in favor of the latter in 1290.
- Τὸ ὑποβληθὲν τῇ Ἱερᾷ Συνόδῳ ἐν χειρογράφῳ πόνημα Ὑμῶν ὑπὸ τὸν τίτλον «Βίος Ἰησοῦ Χριστοῦ» παρέπεμψεν αὔτη τῷ προεδρευόντι αὐτῆς Σεβ. Ἀρχιεπισκόπῳ Σύρου, Τήνου καὶ Ἄνδρου κ. Μεθοδίῳ, ὅπως δι' ἐκθέσεως αὐτοῦ ἀναφέρῃ αὐτῇ, ἂν τὸ περιεχόμενον τοῦ πονήματος τούτου εἶναι σύμφωνον πρὸς τὰς παραδόσεις τῆς Ὀρθοδόξου Ἐκκλησίας.
- To hipovlithèn tí Hiera Sinóðo en xirográfo pónima Imón hipo ton títlon «Víos Isú Xristú» parépempsen ávti tó proeðrevónti avtís Sev. Arkhiepiskópo Síru, Tínu ki Anðru k. Methoðío, ópos ði' ekthéseos avtú anaféri avtí, an to periexómenon tú ponímatos tútu íni símfonon pros tas paraðósis tís Orthoðóksu Ekklisías.
- Το πόνημά σας που υποβλήθηκε σε χειρόγραφο στην Ιερά Σύνοδο με τον τίτλο «Βίος Ιησού Χριστού», παραπέμφθηκε στον πρόεδρό της Σεβ. Αρχιεπίσκοπο Σύρου, Τήνου και Άνδρου κ. Μεθόδιο, ώστε με έκθεσή του να της αναφέρει αν το περιεχόμενο του πονήματος αυτού είναι σύμφωνο με τις παραδόσεις της Ορθόδοξης Εκκλησίας.
- To pónimá sas pu ipovlíthike se xirógrafo stin Ierá Sínoðo me tu títlo «Víos Isú Xristú», parapémfthike ston próeðro tis Sev. Arkhiepískopo Síru, Tínu ki Anðru k. Methóðio, oste me ékthesí tu na tis anaféri an to periexómeno tu ponímatos avtú íni símfono me tis paraðósis tis Orthóðoksis Ekklisías.
- Your work which was submitted in manuscript to the Holy Synod under the title "Life of Jesus Christ", was sent by it [the Holy Synod] to Methodios, its President Archbishop of Syros, Tinos and Andros, so that he may report on whether the content of this work accords with the traditions of the Orthodox Church.
Prerevolutionary discussions
The discussion began at the end of the 18th century, as Eugenios Voulgaris (1716–1806), Lambros Photiadis, St. Kommitas and N. Dukas, who were proponents of a more archaic language, and Voulgaris's students Iosipos Moisiodax (1725–1800) and Dimitrios Katartzis (ca. 1725-1807), who proposed a simpler language, began to voice their opinions. This discussion later became crucial when it was to be decided which one should be the single language of the modern Greek state, which was yet to be founded.
Adamantios KoraisAdamantios Korais or Coraïs was a humanist scholar credited with laying the foundations of Modern Greek literature and a major figure in the Greek Enlightenment. His activities paved the way for the Greek War of Independence and emergence of a purified form of the Greek language, known as...
(1748–1833) influenced the further discussion a lot. While being a supporter of the language of the people, Korais sought to cleanse it from elements that he considered to be too "vulgar" and eventually invented
KatharevousaKatharevousa , is a form of the Greek language conceived in the early 19th century by Greek intellectual and revolutionary leader Adamantios Korais . A graduate of the University of Montpellier in 1788, Korais spent most of his life as an expatriate in Paris...
. After a prolonged
War of IndependenceThe Greek War of Independence was a successful war of independence waged by the Greek revolutionaries between 1821 and 1829, with later assistance from several European powers, against the Ottoman Empire, who were assisted by their vassals, the Egyptian Khedivate and partly the Vilayet of...
, the modern Greek state was founded in 1830; the first capital was
NafplioNafplion or Nauplion is a seaport town in the Peloponnese in Greece that has expanded up the hillsides near the north end of the Argolic Gulf. The town was the first capital of modern Greece, from 1829 to 1834...
and, from 1834 onwards,
AthensAthens , the capital and largest city of Greece, dominates the Attica periphery; as one of the world's oldest cities, its recorded history spans around 3,400 years....
.
Katharevousa officially adopted
KatharevousaKatharevousa , is a form of the Greek language conceived in the early 19th century by Greek intellectual and revolutionary leader Adamantios Korais . A graduate of the University of Montpellier in 1788, Korais spent most of his life as an expatriate in Paris...
was made the official language of the state, since the "unpolished" language of the people was not thought of as able to fit the needs of a modern state. The phanariots, were a group of conservative and educated nobles who supported the archaic language and were the most important critics of the language of the people.
Panagiotis SoutsosPanagiotis Soutsos , was a Greek poet of the romantic school, born in Constantinople . He was an admirer of the ancient Greek tradition, while he used an archaic language in his works...
, who wrote in an increasingly archaic and formal language and should later become one of the most important figures in Athenic romanticism, embraced phanariotic tradition like his brother Alexandros, and, in 1853, he opted for the abolition of Katharevousa and the reintroduction of pure ancient Greek.
Language question becomes widespread
By 1900, the discussion had become a matter of public interest. Proponents of Katharevousa denounced proponents of Dimotiki as "μαλλιαροί" (
hairy, furry), "αγελαίοι" (
gregarious, social, vulgar) and "χυδαϊσταί" (
speakers of slang, plebeians, vulgarians), while the proponents of Dimotiki called their enemies "γλωσσαμύντορες" (
defenders of language, purists), "σκοταδιστές" (
obscurantists, or more or less:
the ones living in spiritual darkness), "αρχαιόπληκτοι" (
ancient-maniacs), "μακαρονισταί" (
imitators of archaic languages,
macaronic people) or "συντηρητικοί" (
conservatives). The educational system was in an alarming state and completely ineffective: The children were completely unable to express themselves in the unfamiliar formal language, which severely harmed their speech acquisition instead of educating them.
Transition to Dimotiki
In the beginning of the 20th century, it was with only the girls' school of
VolosVolos is a coastal port city situated at the center of the Greek mainland, about 326 km north from Athens and 215 km south from Thessaloniki...
that a shift away from the Katharevousa began: Libertarian pedagogue Alexandros Delmouzos implemented the use of the Dimotiki as the language of instruction and thereby achieved considerable improvement in test scores and pupil satisfaction. In spite of this success, clerics and conservatives condemned the reform and protested so vehemently against the school that it was closed.
Orthodox Bishop Fan Noli, who translated into Dimotiki works of Shakespeare and Henrik Ibsen, emphasized the necessity for a people's language and recalled in his memoirs that because of Katharevousa "there were humorous scenes in a comedy and it happened that no one laughed."
By 1917 the Dimotiki had been successfully introduced into primary schools; but again, it was repeatedly replaced with Katharevousa. Only on April 30, 1976 was the era of linguistic purism ended in Greece when
Constantine KaramanlisKonstantinos or Constantine Karamanlis was a Prime Minister, President of Greece and a towering figure of Greek politics whose political career spanned much of the latter half of the 20th century.- Early life :...
' government banned Katharevousa from use in schools and, only a few months later, passed a law concerning the use of the Dimotiki in official texts and documents, which effectively terminated the diglossia. Ironically, the law in question was formulated in Katharevousa.
Further reading
- Carabott, Philip. 1993. Politics, orthodoxy, and the language question in Greece: the Gospel Riots of 1901. Journal of Mediterranean Studies, 3(1):117-138. University of Malta. ISSN: 10163476.