Moral Waiver
Encyclopedia
A moral waiver is an action by United States armed forces
officials to accept, for induction into one of the military services, a recruit who is in one or more of a list of otherwise disqualifying situations.
The mechanism dates from at least the mid-1960s, and was by no later than 1969 part of Army Regulation 601-270. , the "major revision" effective in March 2007 and titled "Military Entrance Processing Station (MEPS)" remains in effect; in that revision, Chapter 9 ("Processing of Selective Service System Registrants"), Section III ("Determination of Moral Qualifications and Waivers") is primarily concerned with moral waiver.
Each disqualifying situation involves at least convictions for multiple minor traffic offenses, or conviction of a more serious charge. The waiver-granting official would be either the commanding officer of the induction center, or the commander of the national induction-center system; the regulations permit even partial discretion as to which of the two applies only in the case of serious juvenile offenses: for
(where the quotation marks are part of the regulation), the induction center commander may either reject the inductee on that commander's own authority, or submit the case for consideration of a moral waiver by the national commander. A single adult felony conviction could be subject to moral waiver, at the discretion of the national commander, but multiple ones are completely disqualifying.
's 1967 folk song and extended monologue "Alice's Restaurant
", is a reference to the moral waiver provision -- the W stands for "waiver"; he described that key element of the work as a waiting area where he mingled with other potential inductees awaiting consideration under moral waiver. The Guthrie work made the expression "Group W bench" (or occasionally simply "Group W") a catchphrase for non-conformity. Various Web sites, an analysis, modeling and research company, and a well established "eclectic boutique" in New Haven, Connecticut
, take their names from it.
In the TV series Lie to Me Season 1 Episode 2 titled Moral Waiver, Sgt Scott was accepted into the military despite having a long list of minor offences.
A Defense Department sponsored report described increased length of tours leading to higher stress which increase manifestations of anger and disrespect for civilians.
Increasing use of moral waivers has implications for killing of noncombatants: John D. Hutson, dean and president of the Franklin Pierce Law Center
in New Hampshire and former judge advocate general of the Navy, said the military must tread carefully in deciding which criminals to accept. He says that there is a reason why allowing people with criminal histories into the military has long been the exception rather than the rule, and
United States armed forces
The United States Armed Forces are the military forces of the United States. They consist of the Army, Navy, Marine Corps, Air Force, and Coast Guard.The United States has a strong tradition of civilian control of the military...
officials to accept, for induction into one of the military services, a recruit who is in one or more of a list of otherwise disqualifying situations.
The mechanism dates from at least the mid-1960s, and was by no later than 1969 part of Army Regulation 601-270. , the "major revision" effective in March 2007 and titled "Military Entrance Processing Station (MEPS)" remains in effect; in that revision, Chapter 9 ("Processing of Selective Service System Registrants"), Section III ("Determination of Moral Qualifications and Waivers") is primarily concerned with moral waiver.
Each disqualifying situation involves at least convictions for multiple minor traffic offenses, or conviction of a more serious charge. The waiver-granting official would be either the commanding officer of the induction center, or the commander of the national induction-center system; the regulations permit even partial discretion as to which of the two applies only in the case of serious juvenile offenses: for
- adverse juvenile adjudication for 1 or more juvenile "felonies"
(where the quotation marks are part of the regulation), the induction center commander may either reject the inductee on that commander's own authority, or submit the case for consideration of a moral waiver by the national commander. A single adult felony conviction could be subject to moral waiver, at the discretion of the national commander, but multiple ones are completely disqualifying.
Popular culture
The Group W bench, a key element of Arlo GuthrieArlo Guthrie
Arlo Davy Guthrie is an American folk singer. Like his father, Woody Guthrie, Arlo often sings songs of protest against social injustice...
's 1967 folk song and extended monologue "Alice's Restaurant
Alice's Restaurant
"Alice's Restaurant Massacree" is a musical monologue by singer-songwriter Arlo Guthrie released on his 1967 album Alice's Restaurant. The song is one of Guthrie's most prominent works, based on a true incident in his life that began on Thanksgiving Day 1965, and which inspired a 1969 movie of the...
", is a reference to the moral waiver provision -- the W stands for "waiver"; he described that key element of the work as a waiting area where he mingled with other potential inductees awaiting consideration under moral waiver. The Guthrie work made the expression "Group W bench" (or occasionally simply "Group W") a catchphrase for non-conformity. Various Web sites, an analysis, modeling and research company, and a well established "eclectic boutique" in New Haven, Connecticut
New Haven, Connecticut
New Haven is the second-largest city in Connecticut and the sixth-largest in New England. According to the 2010 Census, New Haven's population increased by 5.0% between 2000 and 2010, a rate higher than that of the State of Connecticut, and higher than that of the state's five largest cities, and...
, take their names from it.
In the TV series Lie to Me Season 1 Episode 2 titled Moral Waiver, Sgt Scott was accepted into the military despite having a long list of minor offences.
Potential effects in Iraq-War era
In the 2000s, maintaining higher troop levels in the face of higher casualties required two changes in the army. Tours of duty were increased and a higher fraction of volunteers were inducted via moral waivers.A Defense Department sponsored report described increased length of tours leading to higher stress which increase manifestations of anger and disrespect for civilians.
Increasing use of moral waivers has implications for killing of noncombatants: John D. Hutson, dean and president of the Franklin Pierce Law Center
Franklin Pierce Law Center
The University of New Hampshire School of Law, formerly the Franklin Pierce Law Center, is an American Bar Association-accredited law school located in Concord, New Hampshire. It is the only law school in the state. It was founded in 1973 by Robert H...
in New Hampshire and former judge advocate general of the Navy, said the military must tread carefully in deciding which criminals to accept. He says that there is a reason why allowing people with criminal histories into the military has long been the exception rather than the rule, and
- If you are recruiting somebody who has demonstrated some sort of antisocial behavior and then you are a putting a gun in their hands, you have to be awfully careful about what you are doing. You are not putting a hammer in their hands, or asking them to sell used cars. You are potentially asking them to kill people.