All Topics  
Third rail

 
Third Rail

   Email Print
   Bookmark   Link






 

Third rail



 
 
A third rail is a method of providing electricity
Electricity

Electricity is a general term that encompasses a variety of phenomena resulting from the presence and flow of electric charge. These include many easily recognizable phenomena such as lightning and static electricity, but in addition, less familiar concepts such as the electromagnetic field and electromagnetic induction....
 to power a railway
Rail transport

Rail transport is the conveyance of passengers and goods by means of wheeled vehicles running along railways . Rail transport is part of the logistics chain, which facilitates international trade and economic growth....
 through a continuous rigid conductor alongside the railway track or between the rails.






Discussion
Ask a question about 'Third rail'
Start a new discussion about 'Third rail'
Answer questions from other users
Full Discussion Forum



Recent Posts









Encyclopedia


Thirdrail,metro,washington,dc
2402 'county of Hampshire' At Wool
Metro Paris Rubber Wheel
A third rail is a method of providing electricity
Electricity

Electricity is a general term that encompasses a variety of phenomena resulting from the presence and flow of electric charge. These include many easily recognizable phenomena such as lightning and static electricity, but in addition, less familiar concepts such as the electromagnetic field and electromagnetic induction....
 to power a railway
Rail transport

Rail transport is the conveyance of passengers and goods by means of wheeled vehicles running along railways . Rail transport is part of the logistics chain, which facilitates international trade and economic growth....
 through a continuous rigid conductor alongside the railway track or between the rails. It is used typically in a mass transit or rapid transit
Rapid transit

A rapid transit, subway, underground, elevated railway or metro system is an railway electrification system public transport rail transport in an urban area with high capacity and frequency, and which is grade separation from other traffic....
 system, which has alignments in own corridors, fully or almost fully segregated from the outside environment. A list of lines or networks equipped with a third rail is below. Third-rail systems generally supply direct current
Direct current

Direct current is the unidirectional flow of electric charge. Direct current is produced by such sources as battery , thermocouples, solar cells, and commutator-type electric machines of the dynamo type....
 to power the trains. In the early 1900s the third-rail system was used to power early rollercoasters such as the Rough Riders
Rough Riders (rollercoaster)

Rough Riders was a roller coaster built by W.F. Mangels and located on Coney Island's Bowery from 1907 to 1916. It was known for its many amusement park accidents which led it to its closure....
 in Coney Island
Coney Island

Coney Island is a peninsula, formerly an island, in southernmost Brooklyn, New York City, USA, with a beach on the Atlantic Ocean. The Neighbourhood of the same name is a community of 60,000 people in the western part of the peninsula, with Seagate, Brooklyn to its west; Brighton Beach and Manhattan Beach, Brooklyn, New York to its east; a...
, New York.

The third-rail system of electrification is unrelated to the third rail used in dual-gauge railways.

History

Third-rail electric systems are, apart from on-board batteries
Battery (electricity)

In electronics, a battery or voltaic cell is a combination of one or more electrochemical cell Galvanic cells which store chemical energy that can be converted into electric potential energy, creating electricity....
, the oldest means of supplying electric power to train
Train

A train is a connected series of vehicles that move along a track to rail transport from one place to another. The track usually consists of two rail tracks, but might also be a monorail or magnetic levitation train guideway....
s on railways using own corridors, particularly in cities. Overhead power supply was initially almost exclusively used on tramway-like railways, though it also appeared slowly on mainline systems.

An experimental electric train using this method of power supply was developed by the German firm of Siemens & Halske
Siemens AG

Siemens Aktiengesellschaft is Europe's largest engineering Conglomerate . Siemens' international headquarters are located in Berlin and Munich, Germany....
 and shown at the Berlin Industrial Exhibition of 1879, with its third rail between the running rails. Some early electric railways used the running rails as the current conductor, as with the 1883-opened Volk's Electric Railway
Volk's Electric Railway

Volk's Electric Railway is the oldest operating electric railway in the world . It is a narrow gauge railway that runs along a length of the seafront of the England seaside resort of Brighton....
 in Brighton. It was given an additional power rail in 1886, and is still operating. The Giant's Causeway Tramway
Giant's Causeway Tramway

File:Portrush Rly Station, 1890s.jpg The Giant's Causeway Tramway, operated by the Giant's Causeway, Portrush and Bush Valley Railway & Tramway Company Ltd, was a pioneering gauge electric narrow gauge railway operating between Portrush and the Giant's Causeway on the coast of County Antrim, Northern Ireland....
 followed, equipped with an elevated outside third rail in 1883, later converted to overhead wire. The first railway to use the central third rail was the Bessbrook and Newry Tramway in Ireland, opened in 1885 but now, like the Giant's Causeway line, closed. Also in the 1880s third-rail systems began to be used in public urban transport
Public transport

Public transport comprises passenger transportation services which are available for use by the general public, as opposed to modes for private use such as automobiles or vehicles for hire....
. Trams were first to benefit from it: they used conductors in conduit below the road surface (see Conduit current collection
Conduit current collection

Conduit current collection is a system of electric current collection used by electric trams, where the power supply is carried in a channel under the roadway, rather than located overhead....
), usually on selected parts of the networks. This was first tried in Cleveland (1884) and in Denver (1885) and later spread to many big tram networks (e.g. Manhattan, Chicago, Washington DC, London, Paris, all closed) and Berlin (the third rail system in the city was abandoned in the first years of the 20th century after heavy snowfall)).

A third rail supplied power to the world's first electric underground railway, the City & South London Railway
City & South London Railway

The City & South London Railway was the first deep-level underground "tube" railway in the world, and the first major railway in the world to use Railway electrification in Great Britain....
, which opened in 1890 (now part of the Northern Line
Northern Line

The Northern line is a deep-level tube line on the London Underground, coloured black on the Tube map. It carries more passengers per year than any other Underground line; 206,734,000 passengers per annum....
 of the London Underground). In 1893 the world's second third-rail powered city railway opened in Britain, the Liverpool Overhead Railway
Liverpool Overhead Railway

The Liverpool Overhead Railway was the world's first electrically-operated overhead railway. It was located close to the River Mersey in Liverpool, England....
 (closed 1956 and dismantled). The first US third-rail powered city railway in revenue use was the 1895 Metropolitan West Side Elevated, which soon became part of the Chicago 'L'
Chicago 'L'

The 'L' is a rapid transit system that serves the city of Chicago in the United States. It is operated by the Chicago Transit Authority and is the third-busiest rail mass transit system in the United States, behind New York City's New York City Subway and Washington, D.C.'s Washington Metro....
. In 1901, Granville Woods
Granville Woods

Granville T. Woods , was an African American inventor. He was born in Columbus, Ohio and died in New York.Granville T. Woods literally learned his skills on the job....
, a prominent African-American inventor
Inventor

An inventor is a person who creates or discovers a new method, form, device or other useful means. The word inventor comes form the latin verb invenire, invent-, to find....
, was granted a , covering various proposed improvements to third rail systems. This has been cited to claim that he invented the third rail system of current distribution. However, by that time there had been numerous other patents for electrified third-rail systems, including Thomas Edison
Thomas Edison

Thomas Alva Edison was an American inventor and businessman who developed many devices that greatly influenced life around the world, including the phonograph and the long-lasting, practical electric light bulb....
's of 1882, and third rails had been in successful use for over a decade, in installations including the rest of Chicago 'elevateds', as well as these in Brooklyn
Brooklyn

Brooklyn is one of the five Borough of New York City, located at the western end of Long Island. An independent city until its consolidation with New York in 1898, Brooklyn is New York City's most populous borough, with 2.5 million residents, and second largest in area....
, New York (if not to mention the development outside the US). To what extent Woods' ideas were adopted is thus a matter of controversy.

In Paris, third rail appeared in 1900 in the main-line tunnel connecting the Gare d'Orsay
Gare d'Orsay

Gare d'Orsay is a former Parisian railway station and hotel, built in 1900 to designs by Victor Laloux, Lucien Magne and ?mile B?nard; it served as a terminus for the Chemin de Fer de Paris ? Orl?ans ....
 to the rest of the CF Paris-Orléans network. Main-line third rail electrification was later expanded to some suburban services.

Top contact third rail (see below) seems to be the oldest form of power collection. Railways pioneering in using other less hazardous types of third rail were the New York Central Railroad
New York Central Railroad

The New York Central Railroad , known simply as the New York Central in its publicity, was a railroad operating in the Northeastern United States....
 on the approach to its NYC's Grand Central Terminal
Grand Central Terminal

Grand Central Terminal ? often popularly called Grand Central Station or simply Grand Central ? is a Train station#Terminus at 42nd Street and Park Avenue in Midtown Manhattan in New York City....
 (1907 — another case of a third-rail mainline electrification) and the Hochbahn in Hamburg
Hamburg U-Bahn

The Hamburg U-Bahn is a rapid transit system serving the city of Hamburg, Germany. Although technically a subway, most of the system's track length is above ground as with many other Rapid transit in Germany#U-Bahn networks in Germany....
 (1912) — both had bottom contact rail. However, the Manchester-Bury Line of the Lancashire & Yorkshire Railway tried side contact rail in 1917. These technologies appeared in wider use only at the turn of the 1920s and in the 1930s on, e.g., large-profile lines of the Berlin U-Bahn
Berlin U-Bahn

The Berlin is a rapid transit railway in Berlin, Germany, and is a major part of the public transport system of the capital. Opened in 1902, the serves List of Berlin U-Bahn stations spread across nine lines, with a total track length of , about 80% of which is underground....
, the Berlin S-Bahn
Berlin S-Bahn

The Berlin S-Bahn is a rapid transit system operated by S-Bahn Berlin GmbH, a subsidiary of the Deutsche Bahn. The Berlin S-Bahn consists of 15 lines and is integrated with the mostly underground Berlin U-Bahn to form the backbone of Berlin's rapid transport system....
 and the Moscow Metro
Moscow Metro

The Moscow Metro , which spans almost the entire Moscow, is the world's Metro systems by annual passenger rides rapid-transit system. Opened in 1935, it is well known for the ornate design of many of its metro station, which contain outstanding examples of socialist realism art....
. The Hamburg S-Bahn has used a side contact third rail at 1200 V DC since 1939.

In 1956 the world's first rubber-tyred railway line, Line 11 of Paris Metro
Paris Métro

The Paris M?tro or M?tropolitain is the rapid transit system in Paris. It is a symbol of the city, notable for its station architecture, influenced by Art Nouveau....
, opened. The conductor rail evolved into a pair of guiding rails required to keep the bogie in proper position on the new type of track. This solution was modified on the 1971 Namboku Line of Sapporo Subway, where a centrally placed guiding/return rail was used plus one power rail placed laterally as on conventional railways (see photo).

The third rail technology at street tram lines has recently been revived in the new system of Bordeaux
Tramway de Bordeaux

The Bordeaux tramway network consists of three lines serving the city of Bordeaux in southwestern France. The first line was opened on 21 December 2003; further extensions have increased the route length to ....
 (2004). This is a completely new technology (see below).

Third rail is not obsolete. There are, however, countries (particularly Japan, South Korea, India, Spain) more eager to adopt overhead wiring
Pantograph (rail)

A pantograph is a device that collects electric current from overhead lines for electric trains or trams. The term stems from the resemblance to Pantograph for copying writing and drawings....
 to their urban railways. But in the same time there were (and still are) many new third rail systems built elsewhere, including technologically advanced countries (i.e. Copenhagen Metro
Copenhagen Metro

The Copenhagen Metro, also known simply as the Metro, is a railway rapid transit system serving Copenhagen, Frederiksberg and T?rnby, Denmark....
, Taipei Metro, Wuhan Metro
Wuhan Metro

The Wuhan Metro is an elevated and underground rapid transit system in the city of Wuhan, China. It is referred to as a light rail system in Chinese terminology....
). Bottom powered railways (it may be too specific to use the term 'third rail') are also usually those having rubber-tyred trains, whether it is a heavy metro (except two other lines of Sapporo Subway) or a small capacity people mover
People mover

A people mover or automated people mover is a fully automated, grade separation mass transit system. The term is generally used only to describe systems serving relatively small areas such as airports, downtown districts or theme parks, but is sometimes applied to considerably more complex automated systems....
 (PM). Practically the type of railways where third rail is no longer used in new systems is regional and long distance rail, which require higher speeds and voltages.

Top Contact Pickup Shoe
Arcing Pickup Shoe


The world speed record for a third rail train is 174 km/h attained on 11 April 1988 by a British Class 442
British Rail Class 442

The British Rail Class 442 Wessex Electric electrical multiple units, were introduced in 1988 on the South Western Main Line from London Waterloo station to Southampton Central railway station, Bournemouth railway station, Poole railway station and Weymouth railway station....
 EMU.

Running rails for power supply


The first idea for feeding electricity to a train from an external source was by using both rails on which a train runs, whereby each rail is a conductor for each pole insulated by the sleepers. This method is used by most model trains, however it does not work so well for large trains as the sleepers are not good insulators, furthermore the use of insulated wheels or insulated axles is required. As most insulation materials have worse static properties compared with metals used for this purpose, this results in a less stable train vehicle. Nevertheless, it was sometimes used at the beginning of the development of electric trains. The following systems used it:
  • Gross-Lichterfelde Tramway
    Gross-Lichterfelde Tramway

    The Gross Lichterfelde Tramway was the first electrical tramway of the world. It was built by Siemens and went on 16 May 1881 in service. It run originally with direct current from 180 Volt, it got as many model railways over the rails....
  • Ungerer Tramway
    Ungerer Tramway

    The Ungerer Tramway was the first electrical tramway in Munich. It was built by engineer and owner of the Ungerer Bath, August Ungerer to connect the bath with the 750m distant stop of the horse powered tramway....


Some trains used for rides for children at beer festivals also use this method for power supply.

Technical aspects

The third rail is usually located outside the two running rails, but occasionally between them. The electricity is transmitted to the train by means of a sliding shoe, which is held in contact with the rail. On many systems an insulating cover is provided above the third rail to protect employees working near the track; sometimes the shoe is designed to contact the side (called side running) or bottom (called bottom running) of the third rail, allowing the protective cover to be mounted directly to its top surface. When the shoe slides on top, it is referred to as top running. When the shoe slides on the bottom it is not affected by the build-up of snow or leaves.

As with overhead wires, the return current usually flows through one or both running rails, and leakage to ground is not considered serious. Where trains run on rubber tyres, as on parts of the Paris Métro
Paris Métro

The Paris M?tro or M?tropolitain is the rapid transit system in Paris. It is a symbol of the city, notable for its station architecture, influenced by Art Nouveau....
, Mexico City
Mexico City Metro

The 'Mexico City Metro' is a rubber-tyred metro system that serves the metropolitan area of the Mexican Federal District . It is the second-largest metro system in North America after the New York Subway....
 Metro and Santiago Metro
Santiago Metro

Metro de Santiago is South America's most extensive metro system.The rapid transit system serves the city of Santiago, Chile, Chile. It is a network of five lines connecting a total of 107 stations, some of which are still under construction....
, and on all of the Montreal Métro
Montreal Metro

The Montreal Metro is a rubber-tired metro system, and the main form of public transportation underground in the city of Montreal, Quebec, Canada....
, live guide bars must be provided to feed the current. The return is effected through the rails of the conventional track between these guide bars (see rubber-tyred metro
Rubber-tyred metro

A rubber-tyred metro is a form of rapid transit system that uses a mix of road transport and rail transport technology. The vehicles have wheels with rubber tire which run inside a guideway for traction, as well as traditional railway steel wheels with flanges on steel tracks for guidance....
). Another design, with a third rail (current feed, outside the running rails) and fourth rail (current return, half way between the running rails), is used by a few steel-wheel systems, see fourth rail
Railway electrification system

A Railway electrification system supplies Electric potential energy to railway locomotives and multiple units so that they can operate without having an on-board Prime mover ....
. The London Underground
London Underground

The London Underground is a metro system serving a large part of Greater London and neighbouring areas of Essex, Hertfordshire and Buckinghamshire in the UK....
 is the largest of these, see railway electrification in Great Britain
Railway electrification in Great Britain

Railway electrification in Great Britain describes the past and present Railway electrification system used to supply traction current to Rail transport in Great Britain with a chronological record of development, a list of lines using each system, and a history and a technical description of each system....
.

On line M1 of the Milan Metro the third rail is used as the return electrical line (with potential near the ground) and the live electrical connection is made with a sliding block on the side of the car contacting an electrical bar parallel to the track approximately 1 m (3') above rail level. In this manner there are four rails. In the northern part of the line the more common overhead line system is used.

The third rail is an alternative to overhead lines
Overhead lines

Overhead lines or overhead wires are used to transmit electrical energy to trams, trolleybuses or trains at a distance from the energy supply point....
 that transmit power to trains by means of pantograph
Pantograph (rail)

A pantograph is a device that collects electric current from overhead lines for electric trains or trams. The term stems from the resemblance to Pantograph for copying writing and drawings....
s attached to the trains. Whereas overhead-wire systems can operate at 25 kV
25 kV AC

25 kV, 50 Hz AC is a type of railway electrification system. It is one of the most common voltages used for railway electrification systems in the world, especially on High-speed rail....
 or more, using alternating current
Alternating current

In alternating current the movement of electric charge periodically reverses direction. An electric charge would for instance move forward, then backward, then forward, then backward, over and over again....
 (AC), the smaller clearance around a live rail imposes a maximum of about 1200 V (Hamburg S-Bahn
Hamburg S-Bahn

The Hamburg S-Bahn is a railway network for public rapid mass transit in the Hamburg Metropolitan Region. Together the S-Bahn, the Hamburg U-Bahn, the AKN Eisenbahn and the regional railway form the backbone of railway public transport in the city and the surrounding area....
), and direct current
Direct current

Direct current is the unidirectional flow of electric charge. Direct current is produced by such sources as battery , thermocouples, solar cells, and commutator-type electric machines of the dynamo type....
 (DC) is used. Trains on some lines or networks use both power supply modes (cf. below, "Compromise systems").

One method for reducing current losses (and thus increase the spacing of feeder/sub stations, a major cost in third rail electrification) is to use a composite conductor rail of a hybrid aluminium/steel design. The aluminium is a better conductor of electricity, and a running face of stainless steel gives better wear.

There are several ways of attaching the stainless steel to the aluminium. The oldest is a co-extruded method, where the stainless steel is extruded with the aluminium. This method has suffered, in isolated cases, from de-lamination (where the stainless steel separates from the aluminium); this is said to have been eliminated in the latest co-extruded rails. A second method is an aluminium core, upon which two stainless steel sections are fitted as a cap and linear welded along the centre line of the rail. Because aluminium has a higher coefficient of thermal expansion
Coefficient of thermal expansion

When the temperature of a substance changes, the energy that is stored in the intermolecular bonds between atoms changes. When the stored energy increases, so does the length of the molecular bonds....
 than steel, the aluminium and steel must be positively locked to provide a good current collection interface. A third method rivets aluminum bus strips to the web of the steel rail. The photo below-right depicts such a rail.

Advantages


Cost

Third-rail systems are cheaper to install than overhead wire systems, less prone to weather damage (other than flooding and icing, which cause major problems), and better able to fit into areas of reduced vertical clearance, such as tunnels and bridges. In many countries they were perceived as key means of reducing construction costs of tunnels, hence their popularity at underground railways.

Visual appeal

Third-rail systems cause less visual intrusion: they do not need overhead lines
Overhead lines

Overhead lines or overhead wires are used to transmit electrical energy to trams, trolleybuses or trains at a distance from the energy supply point....
, which some people perceive as unsightly. Singapore
Singapore

Singapore , officially the Republic of Singapore, is an island country microstate located at the southern tip of the Malay Peninsula. It lies 137 kilometres north of the equator, south of the Malaysian state of Johor and north of Indonesia's Riau Islands....
, for example, has banned overhead wires on lines outside tunnels. Urban street railways have been built, for example in Bordeaux
Bordeaux

is a Port city on the Garonne in southwest France, with one million inhabitants in its aire urbaine at a 2008 estimate. It is the Capital of the Aquitaine regions of France, as well as the Prefectures in France of the Gironde Departments of France....
, that carry the conductor rail within a slotted box in the center of the track (conduit current collection
Conduit current collection

Conduit current collection is a system of electric current collection used by electric trams, where the power supply is carried in a channel under the roadway, rather than located overhead....
), primarily to avoid unsightly overhead wires and poles. These resemble the cable slot for a street cable car
Cable car (railway)

A cable car or cable railway is a mass transit system using rail cars that are propelled by a continuously moving Wire rope running at a constant speed....
 as seen in San Francisco. Rather than a mechanical grip, an insulated electrical pickup extends into the slot.

Robustness

Third-rail systems are more robust than overhead line systems, as the conductor rail is able to take higher mechanical forces than the contact wire of an overhead line system. The shoegear on a train is designed to shear off if it hits the conductor rail too hard, but as a train has many sets of shoegear, it is able to continue its journey. By contrast a pantograph is more likely to get tangled up in the overhead wires and not be able to continue its journey.

Maintenance access

Because it lies near the ground within easy reach, instead of many feet up in the air, a third rail system allows easy maintenance.

Compatibility

Many railways use a third rail and DC power, even where overhead lines would otherwise be practical, due to the high cost of retrofitting. Every expansion of such system must cope with the problem of compatibility. It usually leads for the choice of already existing technology.

Disadvantages

Third-rail systems have a number of problems and disadvantages, including:

Safety

An unguarded electrified rail carrying more than 50 volts is a safety hazard, and some people have been killed by touching the rail or by stepping on it while attempting to cross the tracks. However, such incidents are usually the result of carelessness on the part of the victim. The principal hazard is probably associated with level crossing
Level crossing

The term level crossing is a crossing on one level ? without recourse to a bridge or tunnel — of a railway line by a road, path, or another railroad....
s (grade crossings). While their number on third rail lines is normally reduced to none, they still occur at some systems, particularly on rural and suburban portions of the network. One notable example of a Metro line running a third rail at ground level is the outer ends of the present Brown Line
Brown Line (Chicago Transit Authority)

The Brown Line of the Chicago 'L' rapid transit system, is an 11.4 mile route with 19 stations between Albany Park, Chicago on the north and Chicago Loop....
 and Pink Line
Pink Line (Chicago Transit Authority)

The Pink Line is a rapid transit line in Chicago, Illinois, run by the Chicago Transit Authority as part of the Chicago 'L' system. It began operation for a 180-day trial period on June 25 2006, running between 54/Cermak in Cicero, Illinois and the The Loop in downtown Chicago....
 of the Chicago 'L'
Chicago 'L'

The 'L' is a rapid transit system that serves the city of Chicago in the United States. It is operated by the Chicago Transit Authority and is the third-busiest rail mass transit system in the United States, behind New York City's New York City Subway and Washington, D.C.'s Washington Metro....
, running on street level in a densely populated neighborhood. The conductor is discontinued in the level crossing area. Pedestrians may be discouraged from trespassing into railway area by means of perforated panels difficult to step on (cattle-cum-trespass guards). They are laid between rails alongside the road.

Intercity ground level third rail systems are the norm in the southeast of England
England

native_name =|conventional_long_name = England|common_name = England|image_flag = Flag of England.svg|image_coat = England COA.svg|symbol_type = Royal Coat of Arms...
, and level crossings are handled in a fashion similar to the Chicago system. A few interurban
Interurban

An Interurban, also called a Toronto radial lines in parts of Canada, is a type of electric passenger rail transport that enjoyed widespread popularity in the first three decades of the twentieth century in North America....
 electric railways attempted to utilize third rail in the USA, but these were quickly abandoned as impractical outside commuter lines such as the New York City
New York City

The City of New York is the List of United States cities by population in the United States, while the New York metropolitan area ranks among the List of urban areas by population....
 Long Island Rail Road
Long Island Rail Road

The Long Island Rail Road or LIRR is a commuter rail system serving the length of Long Island, New York that has been classified as a Class II railroad by the Surface Transportation Board....
. Both the US and UK intercity systems address safety through extensive fencing and warning signage.

There are urban legends that people have died while urinating on the third rail (the urine stream supposedly completes an electrical circuit that electrocutes the victim); a non-continuous stream has been demonstrated by MythBusters
MythBusters

MythBusters is a popular science television program produced by Australian firm Beyond Television Productions originally for the Discovery Channel in the United States and Canada....
 (Season 1, Episode 3) to be unable to conduct electricity . This myth may be partially perpetuated by a 1977 incident that occurred in Chicago where an intoxicated pedestrian suffered a fatal electrocution injury while trespassing to urinate on the grade-level CTA Brown Line near Kedzie Avenue. However, the death occurred as a result of the passenger making physical contact with the third rail, not as a result of an electrical circuit being completed via his urine stream. However a recent event at Vauxhall station in London may perpetuate this myth.
Bart Third Rails
There are also myths about people urinating on overhead wires from a bridge. Also people have been killed by overhead wires while passing a standing train by climbing over it. So both variants of electric supply are dangerous.

Potential solutions
  • A new tram
    Tram

    A tram, tramcar, trolley, trolley car, or streetcar is a railroad car, of lighter weight and construction than a train, designed for the transport of passengers within, close to, or between villages, towns and/or cities, on tracks running primarily on streets....
    way in Bordeaux
    Bordeaux

    is a Port city on the Garonne in southwest France, with one million inhabitants in its aire urbaine at a 2008 estimate. It is the Capital of the Aquitaine regions of France, as well as the Prefectures in France of the Gironde Departments of France....
    , France
    France

    France , officially the French Republic , is a country whose Metropolitan France is located in Western Europe and that also comprises various Overseas departments and territories of France....
     surmounts the safety problem by using a third rail divided into insulated segments only a few metres long. Each segment is live only while completely covered by a tram, so there is no risk of a person or animal coming into contact with a live rail (see Third-rail power for trams
    Light rail

    Light rail or light rail transit is a form of urban rail transit public transportation that generally has a lower capacity and lower speed than Passenger_rail_terminology#Heavy_rail and rapid transit systems, but higher capacity and higher speed than street-running tram systems....
     and stud contact electrification for more information). This system would not be suitable for higher speeds, and the cost of breaking the live rail into short sections is considerable. This system was developed mainly for aesthetic reasons, to avoid overhead wires in front of the town hall.


  • Other safety precautions can be made to reduce the risk of the third rail. Many subways, such as BART
    Bay Area Rapid Transit

    Bay Area Rapid Transit is a rapid transit system serving the San Francisco Bay Area. The Passenger rail terminology#Heavy rail public transit system connects downtown San Francisco with suburbs in the East Bay and northern San Mateo County, California....
     and the Washington Metro
    Washington Metro

    The Washington Metro is the rapid transit system in Washington, D.C. and its surrounding suburbs. The system is administered by the Washington Metropolitan Area Transit Authority ....
    , use sheaths to cover their third rails and always place the rail on the farther side of the track away from where passengers would normally be. If someone falls on the tracks, there is room to return safely to the platform (or crawl under the platform) without stepping on the third rail.


Limited capacity

A relatively low voltage is necessary in a third-rail system — otherwise, electricity would arc from the rail to the ground or the running rails — but the resulting higher current (sometimes upwards of 3000 amperes) causes more proportional voltage drop per mile, meaning that electrical feeder sub-stations have to be set up at frequent intervals along the line (generally no more than apart), increasing operating costs. A 1992 report, prepared for the California Department of Transportation
California Department of Transportation

The California Department of Transportation is a government department in the U.S. state of California. Its mission is to improve mobility across the state....
 by Morrison-Knudsen Corporation
Washington Group International

Washington Group International was an American corporation which provided integrated engineering, construction and management services to businesses and governments around the world....
, states that typical spacing of substations supplying a 600 volt DC track is one mile apart, and the cost of electrifying with third rail is nearly double that of overhead catenary
Catenary

In physics and geometry, the catenary is the theoretical shape of a hanging flexible chain or cable when supported at its ends and acted upon by a uniform gravity force and in equilibrium....
. The low voltage also means that the system is prone to overload, which makes such systems unsuitable for freight or high-speed trains demanding high amounts of power. These limitations of third-rail systems have largely restricted their use to mass transit systems. Capacity is also limited by speed restrictions. Testing on the Southern Region of British Rail during the late 1980s/early 1990s established that third rail could handle 160 km/h (100 mph) and that third rail could provide reliable current collection. Testing at greater speeds was not tried as the track tested had a maximum speed of 160 km/h (100 mph).

By comparison, overhead wires can provide 50 kV, and can take roughly ten times the power.

Infrastructure restrictions

Junctions and other pointwork make it necessary to leave gaps in the live rail at times, as do level crossing
Level crossing

The term level crossing is a crossing on one level ? without recourse to a bridge or tunnel — of a railway line by a road, path, or another railroad....
s. This is not usually a problem, as most third-rail rolling stock has multiple current collection shoes along the length of the train, but under certain circumstances it is possible for a train to become "gapped" — stalled with none of its shoes in contact with the live rail. When this happens, it is usually necessary for the train to be shunted back onto a live section either by a rescue locomotive or another service train, although in some circumstances it is possible to use jumper cables to temporarily hook the train's current collectors to the nearest section of live rail. Given that gapping tends to happen at complex, important junctions, it can be a major source of disruption. On the Chicago Transit Authority
Chicago Transit Authority

Chicago Transit Authority, also known as CTA, is the operator of public transport within the Chicago, Illinois. It is the second largest transit system in the United States and fourth largest in North America....
 system the jumper cables are known as stingers; they are insulated poles with a wired contact that may be manually pressed against contact shoes to restart a gapped train. Other such problems are implementation-specific and usually have workarounds. Another infrastructure restriction of third rail is that the rail and its safety cover decrease the structure gauge
Structure gauge

The structure gauge, also called the minimum clearance outline, is the minimum size of tunnels and bridges as well as the minimum size of the doors that allow a rail siding access into a warehouse....
 and in turn the loading gauge
Loading gauge

A loading gauge is the envelope or contoured shape within which all railroad cars, locomotives, Coach es, buses, trucks and other vehicles, must fit....
, potentially blocking access to certain types of equipment.

When David L. Gunn
David L. Gunn

David L. Gunn is a transportation system administrator who has headed several important railroads and transit systems in North America.Gunn was born in Boston, Massachusetts to parents of Canada ancestry whose families had emigrated to Massachusetts from Nova Scotia and Dominion of Newfoundland....
 became General Manager
General manager

General Manager or GM for short is a descriptive term for certain corporate officers in a business operation. It is also a formal title held by some business executives, most commonly in the hospitality industry....
 of the Washington D.C. Metrorail in 1991, he proposed to alleviate crowding by running much more frequent trains as two-car trains instead of the practice the transit authority had of running four-car trains. He had to publicly drop this idea, with some embarrassment, when it was pointed out to him that two-car trains can operate only in specific areas of the system because each car only has one shoe, on the same side of the car. Even with the practice of having each car pointing in the opposite direction so that there is a shoe on each side of the train, there are many places in the system where a two-car train would end up gapped.

Inefficient contact

Fallen leaves, snow and other debris on the conductor rail can reduce the efficiency of the contact between the conductor rail and the pickup shoes, leaving trains stalled because of the lack of power. Bottom-contact third rail, as used on the Metro-North Railroad
Metro-North Railroad

The Metro-North Commuter Railroad , trading as MTA Metro-North Railroad, or, more commonly, Metro-North, is a suburban Regional rail service that is run and managed by the Metropolitan Transportation Authority , an New York State public benefit corporations of New York State....
 (see Technical aspects above), and numerous other transit systems including the Docklands Light Railway
Docklands Light Railway

The Docklands Light Railway is a light rail system serving the redeveloped London Docklands area of East London, England....
 in London
London

London is the capital of both England and the United Kingdom, and the most populous municipality in the European Union. An important settlement for two millennia, History of London goes back to its founding by the Roman Empire....
 and the Market-Frankford Line
Market-Frankford Line

The Market?Frankford Line is a rapid transit line in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, operated by the SEPTA....
 in Philadelphia
Philadelphia, Pennsylvania

Philadelphia is the largest city in Pennsylvania and the List of United States cities by population city in the United States. It is the fifth-largest metropolitan area and fourth-largest urban area by population in the United States, the nation's fourth-largest consumer media market as ranked by the Nielsen Media Research, and the 49th-most...
, is highly resistant to this problem.

Older systems adopted top-contact third rail before they realised that there would be problems with leaves, etc., while newer systems have learned from this mistake and use side or bottom contact. However, some relatively new systems in North America, such as the TTC
Toronto Transit Commission

The Toronto Transit Commission is a public transport authority that operates buses, Tram, Rapid transits, and rapid transit lines in Toronto, Ontario, Canada....
 in Toronto
Toronto

Toronto is the List of the 100 largest municipalities in Canada by population in Canada and the Provinces and territories of Canada Provincial and territorial capitals of Canada of Ontario....
, use top-covered top-contact third rails on above-ground portions of its subway system; rarely is the system delayed by electrical problems even after heavy snows. Problems generally arise in other aspects of the system (frozen switches for example) long before snow interferes significantly with electrical pickup. Some systems are less susceptible to this problem due to having mostly underground trackage, or less severe weather.

Compromise systems

Several systems use third rail for part of the system, and other systems such as overhead catenary
Catenary

In physics and geometry, the catenary is the theoretical shape of a hanging flexible chain or cable when supported at its ends and acted upon by a uniform gravity force and in equilibrium....
 or diesel power for the remainder. These may exist because of the connection of separately-owned railways using the different systems, local ordinances, or other historical accidents.

USA

In New York City
New York City

The City of New York is the List of United States cities by population in the United States, while the New York metropolitan area ranks among the List of urban areas by population....
, electric trains that must use third rail leaving Grand Central Terminal
Grand Central Terminal

Grand Central Terminal ? often popularly called Grand Central Station or simply Grand Central ? is a Train station#Terminus at 42nd Street and Park Avenue in Midtown Manhattan in New York City....
 on the former New York Central Railroad
New York Central Railroad

The New York Central Railroad , known simply as the New York Central in its publicity, was a railroad operating in the Northeastern United States....
 (now Metro-North Railroad
Metro-North Railroad

The Metro-North Commuter Railroad , trading as MTA Metro-North Railroad, or, more commonly, Metro-North, is a suburban Regional rail service that is run and managed by the Metropolitan Transportation Authority , an New York State public benefit corporations of New York State....
) switch to overhead lines
Overhead lines

Overhead lines or overhead wires are used to transmit electrical energy to trams, trolleybuses or trains at a distance from the energy supply point....
 at Pelham when they need to operate out onto the former New York, New Haven and Hartford Railroad
New York, New Haven and Hartford Railroad

The New York, New Haven and Hartford Railroad was a railroad that operated in the northeast United States from 1872 to 1968. Commonly referred to as the New Haven, the railroad served the states of Connecticut, New York, Rhode Island, and Massachusetts....
 (now Metro North's New Haven Line) line to Connecticut
Connecticut

Connecticut is a U.S. state located in the New England region of the northeastern United States. The state borders New York to the west and south , Massachusetts to the north, and Rhode Island to the east....
. The switch is made "on the fly" controlled from the engineer's position.

Also in New York City, due to a prohibition on diesel emissions in tunnels, Metro-North, Long Island Rail Road
Long Island Rail Road

The Long Island Rail Road or LIRR is a commuter rail system serving the length of Long Island, New York that has been classified as a Class II railroad by the Surface Transportation Board....
 and Amtrak
Amtrak

The National Railroad Passenger Corporation, doing business as Amtrak , is a government-owned corporation that was organized on May 1, 1971 to provide Inter-city rail train#Passenger trains service in the United States....
 use diesel locomotives that can also be electrically powered by third-rail. This kind of locomotive (for example the P32AC-DM or the EMD/Siemens built DM30AC of LIRR), can transition between the two modes while underway. The third-rail auxiliary system is not as powerful as the diesel engine, so on open-air (non-tunnel) trackage run the engines typically run in diesel mode, even where third rail power is available. This does not hold true for the DM30ACs, where the electric mode is much more powerful than the diesel.

In Manhattan
Manhattan

Manhattan is one of the five borough of New York City, located primarily on Manhattan Island at the mouth of the Hudson River.With a United States Census of 1,620,867 living in a land area of 22.96 square miles , Manhattan, coextensive with New York County, is the most population density county in the United States, w...
, New York City, and in Washington, D.C.
Washington, D.C.

Washington, D.C. , formally the District of Columbia and commonly referred to as Washington, the District, or simply D.C., is the Capital of the United States, founded on July 16, 1790....
, local ordinances required electrified street railways to draw current from a third rail and return the current to a fourth rail, both installed in a continuous vault underneath the street and accessed by means of a collector that passed through a slot between the running rails. When streetcars on such systems entered territory where overhead lines were allowed, they stopped over a pit where a man detached the collector (plow) and the motorman
Motorman

A motorman is the person who operates an electrified tram car, tram, light rail, or rapid transit train.The term refers to the person who is in charge of the motor in the same sense as a railroad engineer is in charge of the engine....
 placed a trolley pole
Trolley pole

A trolley pole is a tapered cylindrical pole of wood or metal, used to transfer electricity from a "live" overhead lines to the control and propulsion equipment of a tram or trolley bus....
 on the overhead. Some sections of the former London
London

London is the capital of both England and the United Kingdom, and the most populous municipality in the European Union. An important settlement for two millennia, History of London goes back to its founding by the Roman Empire....
 tram system also used the conduit current collection
Conduit current collection

Conduit current collection is a system of electric current collection used by electric trams, where the power supply is carried in a channel under the roadway, rather than located overhead....
 system, also with some tramcars that could collect power from both overhead and under-road sources.

The Blue Line
Blue Line (MBTA)

The Blue Line is one of four rapid transit lines of the Massachusetts Bay Transportation Authority. It runs from northeast to southwest, extending from Wonderland in Revere, Massachusetts to Bowdoin near Beacon Hill, Boston, Massachusetts in Boston, Massachusetts....
 of Boston's
Boston, Massachusetts

Boston is the State capital and largest city of the Commonwealth of Massachusetts, and is one of the oldest cities in the United States. The largest city in New England, Boston is considered the economic and cultural center of the region, and is sometimes regarded as the unofficial "Capital of New England." Boston city proper had a 2007 est...
 MBTA
Massachusetts Bay Transportation Authority

The Massachusetts Bay Transportation Authority is "a body politic and corporate, and a political subdivision" of the Commonwealth of Massachusetts formed in 1964 to finance and operate most bus, Rapid transit, commuter rail and ferry systems in the greater Boston, Massachusetts, Massachusetts, area....
 uses third rail electrification from the start of the line downtown to Airport
Airport (MBTA station)

The Airport Station on the Massachusetts Bay Transportation Authority Blue Line provides a mass transit connection to Logan International Airport ....
, where it switches to overhead catenary for the remainder of the line to Wonderland
Wonderland (MBTA station)

Wonderland is the northern terminus of the Blue Line in the Massachusetts Bay Transportation Authority mass transit system serving greater Boston, Massachusetts....
. Dual power supply method was also used on some US interurban
Interurban

An Interurban, also called a Toronto radial lines in parts of Canada, is a type of electric passenger rail transport that enjoyed widespread popularity in the first three decades of the twentieth century in North America....
 railways that made use of newer third rail in suburban areas, and existing overhead streetcar (trolley) infrastructure to reach downtown, for example the Skokie Swift in Chicago.

UK

Eurostar At Vauxhall
Several types of British trains operate on both overhead and third rail systems, including class 313
British Rail Class 313

Class 313 electric multiple units were built by BREL at York Works from 1976-1977, these being the first List of British Rail classes#Second Generation EMUs to be constructed for British Rail....
, 319
British Rail Class 319

The British Rail Class 319 dual-voltage electric multiple units were built by BREL York in two batches in 1987?88 and 1990. The trains were introduced for new north-south cross-London services from Bedford to Brighton, and since privatisation these services have been operated by Thameslink and First Capital Connect, the former franchise...
, 325
British Rail Class 325

The British Rail Class 325 is a dual-voltage alternating current electric multiple unit train used for postal train services. They have a similar end-on cab appearance to the British Rail Class 365 and British Rail Class 465 Networker units built at approximately the same time....
, 377/2
British Rail Class 377

The Class 377 Electrostars are electric multiple units built by Bombardier Transportation at their Derby Carriage and Wagon Works, from 2001 to the present....
 and formerly by 373
British Rail Class 373

The British Rail Class 373 or TGV-TMST train is an electric multiple unit that operates Eurostar's high-speed rail service between Great Britain, France and Belgium via the Channel Tunnel....
 Eurostar
Eurostar

Eurostar is a high-speed train service in Western Europe connecting London and Kent in the United Kingdom, with Paris and Lille in France, and Brussels in Belgium....
 trains.

The Eurostar
Eurostar

Eurostar is a high-speed train service in Western Europe connecting London and Kent in the United Kingdom, with Paris and Lille in France, and Brussels in Belgium....
 uses overhead electrical power (at 25 kV AC) in the Channel Tunnel
Channel Tunnel

The Channel Tunnel , also known by the portmanteau Chunnel, is a undersea rail transport tunnel linking Folkestone, Kent, Kent in England with Coquelles near Calais in northern France beneath the English Channel at the Strait of Dover....
 and along High Speed 1, with a pantograph height change required between HS1 and the Channel Tunnel (which is at a unique height). Until 14 November 2007, at Fawkham Junction
Fawkham Junction

Fawkham Junction is a rail transport junction that currently connects High Speed 1 with the Chatham Main Line.Originally the Junction was part of the London, Chatham and Dover Railway's Gravesend West Line to Gravesend, Kent ....
 a transition was made on the fly to 750 V DC for the journey through the London
London

London is the capital of both England and the United Kingdom, and the most populous municipality in the European Union. An important settlement for two millennia, History of London goes back to its founding by the Roman Empire....
 suburbs on the standard commuter lines into Waterloo using the third rail system. There are now 25 kV overhead wires all the way into St. Pancras International
St Pancras railway station

St Pancras railway station is a major railway station situated in the St Pancras, London area of central London between the British Library and London King's Cross railway station....
 station.

Also in London, the North London Line
North London Line

The North London Line is a railway line through the inner suburbs of north London, England, from Richmond station in the west to North Woolwich railway station in the east in roughly a semi-circle....
 changes its power supply several times between Richmond
Richmond tube station

Richmond station is a London Underground and National Rail station, located in Richmond, London in the London Borough of Richmond upon Thames in south west London....
 and Stratford
Stratford station

Stratford station is a railway station in Stratford, London, London Borough of Newham, East London, England on National Rail, London Underground and Docklands Light Railway lines....
. The cross-city Thameslink
Thameslink

Thameslink is a fifty-station route in the Rail transport in the United Kingdom running north to south from Bedford railway station to Brighton railway station through the Snow Hill tunnel in Central London....
 service runs on Southern Region third rail from Farringdon station
Farringdon station

Farringdon station is a London Underground and National Rail station in Clerkenwell, just north of the City of London in the London Borough of Islington....
 southwards and on overhead line northwards from Farringdon to Bedford: this change-over is made while stationary.

Continental Europe

The older lines in the west of the Oslo T-bane
Oslo T-bane

Oslo T-bane is the rapid transit system of Oslo, Norway, operated by Oslo T-banedrift on contract from the transit authority Ruter. The network consists of six lines that all run through the city center, with a total length of ....
 system were built with overhead lines (some since converted to third rail) while the eastern lines were built with third rail. Trains operating on the older lines can operate both with third rail and overhead lines. To mitigate investment costs, the Rotterdam Metro
Rotterdam Metro

The Rotterdam Metro is a rapid transit system operated in Rotterdam by Rotterdamse Elektrische Tram. The first line, called Noord - Zuidlijn opened in 1968 and ran from Rotterdam#Train to Zuidplein, crossing the river Nieuwe Maas in a tunnel....
, basically a third-rail powered system, has been given some outlying branches built on surface as light rail
Light rail

Light rail or light rail transit is a form of urban rail transit public transportation that generally has a lower capacity and lower speed than Passenger_rail_terminology#Heavy_rail and rapid transit systems, but higher capacity and higher speed than street-running tram systems....
 (called 'Sneltram' in Dutch), with numerous level crossings protected with barriers and traffic lights. These branches have overhead wires. Similarly, in Amsterdam one 'Sneltram' route goes on Metro
Amsterdam Metro

The Amsterdam Metro is a mixed rapid transit and light rail system in Amsterdam, and its surrounding municipalities Amstelveen, Diemen, and Ouder-Amstel, in the Netherlands....
 tracks and passes to surface alignment in the suburbs, which it shares with standard trams. In most recent developments, the RandstadRail
RandstadRail

RandstadRail is a light rail project in the southern area of the Randstad conurbation in the west of The Netherlands. It connects the cities of The Hague, Zoetermeer and Rotterdam, also serving the suburban areas between them....
 project also requires Rotterdam Metro trains to run under wires on their way along the former mainline railway to The Hague.

The new tramway in Bordeaux
Bordeaux

is a Port city on the Garonne in southwest France, with one million inhabitants in its aire urbaine at a 2008 estimate. It is the Capital of the Aquitaine regions of France, as well as the Prefectures in France of the Gironde Departments of France....
 (France
France

France , officially the French Republic , is a country whose Metropolitan France is located in Western Europe and that also comprises various Overseas departments and territories of France....
) uses a novel system with a third rail in the center of the track. The third rail is separated into 8 m (26 ' 3 ") long conducting and 3 m (9 ' 10 ") long isolation segments. Each conducting segment is attached to an electronic circuit which will make the segment live once it lies fully beneath the tram (activated by a coded signal sent by the train) and switch it off before it becomes exposed again. This system (called "Alimentation par Sol" (APS), meaning "current supply via ground") is used in various locations around the city but especially in the historic centre: elsewhere the trams use the conventional overhead lines
Overhead lines

Overhead lines or overhead wires are used to transmit electrical energy to trams, trolleybuses or trains at a distance from the energy supply point....
, see also ground-level power supply
Ground-level power supply

Ground-level power supply, also known as surface current collection and Alimentation par Sol is a modern method of third rail electrical pick-up for street trams....
. In summer 2006 it was announced that two new French tram systems would be using APS over part of their networks. These will be Angers
Angers

Angers is a city in the Maine-et-Loire Departments of France in northwestern France about south-west of Paris. Angers is located in the French region known by its pre-revolutionary, provincial name, Anjou, and its inhabitants are called Angevins....
 and Reims
Reims

The city of Reims lies in the Champagne-Ardenne region in northeastern France 129 km east-northeast of Paris.Founded by the Gauls, it became a major city during the period of the Roman Empire....
, with both systems expected to open around 2009–2010.

The French Fréjus line
Fréjus railway

The Fr?jus railway is the international rail connection from Torino, Italy to Modane, France. It passes through the Susa Valley and the Fr?jus Rail Tunnel....
 to Modane
Modane

Modane is a commune in France of the Savoie D?partements of France in France.It was part ot the Kingdom of Sardinia until 1861....
 was electrified with 1500 V DC third rail, later converted to overhead wires at the same voltage. Stations had overhead wires from the beginning.

Conversions

Despite various technical possibilities of operating stock with dual power collecting modes, the desire to achieve full compatibility of entire networks seems to have been the decisive cause of conversions from third rail to overhead supply (or vice versa).

Suburban corridors in Paris from Gare Saint-Lazare
Gare Saint-Lazare

Gare Saint-Lazare is one of the six large terminus train stations of Paris. It is the second busiest in Europe, behind the Gare du Nord, handling 450,000 passengers each day, including the metro station , and serves several lines to Normandy....
, Gare des Invalides (both CF Ouest) and Gare d'Orsay
Gare d'Orsay

Gare d'Orsay is a former Parisian railway station and hotel, built in 1900 to designs by Victor Laloux, Lucien Magne and ?mile B?nard; it served as a terminus for the Chemin de Fer de Paris ? Orl?ans ....
 (CF PO
Chemin de Fer de Paris à Orléans

The Chemin de Fer de Paris ? Orl?ans, often abbreviated to CF Paris-Orl?ans, was an early France railway.In 1934 it merged with the Chemin de Fer du Midi to become part of the Chemin de Fer de Paris ? Orl?ans et du Midi ....
), were electrified from 1924, 1901, 1900 respectively. They all changed to overhead wires by stages after they became part of a wide scale electrification project of the SNCF
SNCF

SNCF is a France public enterprise. Its functions include operation of rail services for passengers and freight, and maintenance as well as signalling of rail infrastructure owned by R?seau Ferr? de France ....
 network in the 1960s–70s.

In Manchester area, the L&YR
Lancashire and Yorkshire Railway

The Lancashire and Yorkshire Railway was a major History of rail transport in Great Britain before the Railways Act 1921. It was Incorporation_#Incorporation_in_the_United_Kingdom in 1847 from an amalgamation of several existing Rail transport....
Bury line was first electrified with overhead wires (1913), then changed to third rail (1917, cf. Railway electrification in Great Britain
Railway electrification in Great Britain

Railway electrification in Great Britain describes the past and present Railway electrification system used to supply traction current to Rail transport in Great Britain with a chronological record of development, a list of lines using each system, and a history and a technical description of each system....
) and again in 1992 to overhead wires in the course of its adaptation for the Manchester Metrolink
Manchester Metrolink

Manchester Metrolink is an urban light rail system in Greater Manchester, England. It consists of three lines which run between Central Manchester and the surrounding towns of Bury, Altrincham and Eccles, Greater Manchester....
. Trams in city centre streets, carrying collector shoes projecting from their bogies, were considered too dangerous for pedestrians and motor traffic to attempt dual-mode technology (in Amsterdam and Rotterdam Sneltram vehicles go out to surface in suburbs, not in busy central areas). The same thing happened to the West Croydon — Wimbledon Line in Greater London (originally electrified by the Southern Railway) when Tramlink
Tramlink

Tramlink is a tramway system in south London in the United Kingdom which began operation in May 2000. The service is operated by First London on behalf of Transport for London ....
 was opened in 2000.

Three lines of five making up the core of Barcelona Metro
Barcelona Metro

The Barcelona Metro , part of the mass transit public transport system of Barcelona, Catalonia, Spain is an extensive network of electrified railways that run underground in central Barcelona and above ground into the city's suburbs....
 network changed to overhead power supply from third rail. This operation was also done by stages and completed in 2003.

The opposite took place in south London. The South London Line of the LBSCR
London, Brighton and South Coast Railway

The London, Brighton and South Coast Railway was a railway company in the United Kingdom from 1846 to 1922. Its territory formed a rough triangle, with London at its apex, practically the whole coastline of Sussex as its base, and a large part of Surrey....
 network between Victoria and London Bridge was electrified with catenary in 1909. The system was later extended to Crystal Palace, Coulsdon North
Coulsdon North railway station

Coulsdon North is a closed railway station on the Brighton Main Line....
 and Sutton. In the course of main-line third rail electrification in south-east England, the lines were converted by 1929.

The first overhead electric trains appeared on the :de:Hamburg-Altonaer Stadt- und Vorortbahn in 1907. Thirty years later, the main-line railway operator, Deutsche Reichsbahn
Deutsche Reichsbahn

Deutsche Reichsbahn was the name of the following two companies:* Deutsche Reichsbahn, the German Imperial Railways during the Weimar Republic, the Third Reich and the immediate aftermath ...
, influenced by the success of the third-rail Berlin S-Bahn
Berlin S-Bahn

The Berlin S-Bahn is a rapid transit system operated by S-Bahn Berlin GmbH, a subsidiary of the Deutsche Bahn. The Berlin S-Bahn consists of 15 lines and is integrated with the mostly underground Berlin U-Bahn to form the backbone of Berlin's rapid transport system....
, decided to switch what was now called Hamburg S-Bahn
Hamburg S-Bahn

The Hamburg S-Bahn is a railway network for public rapid mass transit in the Hamburg Metropolitan Region. Together the S-Bahn, the Hamburg U-Bahn, the AKN Eisenbahn and the regional railway form the backbone of railway public transport in the city and the surrounding area....
 to third rail. The process began in 1940 and was not finished until 1955.

In 1976–1981 the third-rail Viennese U-Bahn
Vienna U-Bahn

The Vienna U-Bahn is a rapid transit system consisting of five lines mostly running underground, except for the central section of line U6, which runs above ground on the viaduct of the old Vienna Stadtbahn....
 U4 Line substituted the Donaukanallinie and Wientallinie of the Stadtbahn
Wiener Stadtbahn

The Wiener Stadtbahn was a public transportation system operated under this name from 1898 to 1989. Today, the Vienna U-Bahn lines U4 and U6 and the Vienna S-Bahn run on its former lines....
, built c1900 and first electrified with overhead wires in 1924. This was part of a big project of consolidated U-Bahn network construction. The other electric Stadtbahn line, whose conversion into heavy rail stock was rejected, still operates under wires with light rail cars (as U6), though it has been thoroughly modernised and significantly extended. As the platforms on the Gürtellinie were not suitable for raising without much intervention into historic Otto Wagner
Otto Wagner

Otto Koloman Wagner was an Austrian architect.Wagner was born in Penzing , a suburb of Vienna. He studied in Berlin and Vienna. In 1864, he started designing his first buildings in the historicist style....
's station architecture, the line would anyway remain incompatible with the rest of the U-Bahn network. Therefore an attempt of conversion to third rail would have been pointless. In Vienna, paradoxically, the wires were retained for aesthetic (and economic) reasons.

The western portion of the Skokie Swift
Yellow Line (Chicago Transit Authority)

The Yellow Line , is part of the Chicago Transit Authority's Chicago 'L' Rapid transit system in Chicago, Illinois. The 5.1 mile , non-stop shuttle route runs from the Howard on the northern city limits of Chicago, through the southern part of suburban Evanston, Illinois, to the Skokie in Skokie, Illinois....
 of the Chicago 'L'
Chicago 'L'

The 'L' is a rapid transit system that serves the city of Chicago in the United States. It is operated by the Chicago Transit Authority and is the third-busiest rail mass transit system in the United States, behind New York City's New York City Subway and Washington, D.C.'s Washington Metro....
 changed from catenary wire to third rail in 2004, making it fully compatible with the rest of the system.

The reasons for building the overhead powered Tyne & Wear Metro network roughly on lines of the long-gone third-rail Tyneside Electrics
Tyneside Electrics

The Tyneside Electrics refers to the suburban railways on Tyneside that were electrified by the North Eastern Railway from 1904 onwards and formed one of the earliest suburban electric networks....
 system in Newcastle area are likely to have roots in economy and psychology rather than in the pursue of compatibility. At the time of the Metro opening (1980) there were no third-rail light rail vehicles on the market and the latter technology was confined to much more costly heavy rail stock. Also the far-going change of image was desired: the memories of the last stage of operation of the Tyneside Electrics were far from being favourable. This was the construction of the system from scratch after 11 years of ineffective diesel service.

Simultaneous use with overhead wire


A railway can be electrified with an overhead wire and a third rail at the same time. This was the case, for example, on the Hamburg S-Bahn between 1940 and 1955. A modern example is Birkenwerder Railway Station near Berlin, which has third rail on both sides and overhead wire. The whole Penn Station
Pennsylvania Station (New York City)

Pennsylvania Station—commonly known as Penn Station—is the major intercity train station and a major commuter rail hub in New York City....
 complex in New York City is also electrified with both systems. However, such systems have problems with the influence of the different supplies. If one supply is DC and the other AC, an undesired premagnetization of the AC transformers can occur. For this reason, double electrification
Double electrification

Double electrification is a system whereby a railway line is supplied power both via overhead catenary and a third rail. This is done to enable trains that use either system of power to share the same railway line, for example in the case of mainline and suburban trains ....
 is usually avoided.

The border station of Modane on the French-Italian Fréjus railway
Fréjus railway

The Fr?jus railway is the international rail connection from Torino, Italy to Modane, France. It passes through the Susa Valley and the Fr?jus Rail Tunnel....
 was electrified at both 1500 V DC third rail for French trains and with overhead wires (initially three-phase, later 3000 V DC) for Italian trains. When the French part of the line was converted to overhead wires, the voltage of the wires was dropped to 1500 V DC. Now Italian trains run in Modane feed with 1500 V DC instead of 3000, with half of their power.

In model trains


In 1906, the famous Lionel electric trains became the first model trains to use a third rail to power the locomotive. Lionel track uses a third rail in the center, while the two outer rails are electrically connected together. This solved the problem two-rail model trains have when the track is arranged to loop back on itself, as ordinarily this causes a short-circuit. (Even if the loop was gapped, the locomotive would create a short and stop as it crossed the gaps.) Lionel electric trains also operate on alternating current. The use of alternating current means that a Lionel locomotive cannot be reversed by changing polarity; instead, the locomotive sequences among several states (forward, neutral, backward, for example) each time it is started. Märklin three-rail trains use a short spike of voltage to reverse a relay within the locomotive while it is stopped.

Most model train sets today use only two rails, and supply locomotives with direct current. The voltage and polarity of the current controls the speed and direction of the train. A growing exception is DCC (Digital Command Control
Digital Command Control

Digital Command Control systems are used to operate locomotive on a model railroad . Equipped with DCC, locomotives on the same electrical section of track can be independently controlled....
), where bi-polar DC is delivered to the rails at a constant voltage, along with digital signals that are decoded within the locomotive; the signals carry addresses that indicate which locomotive is being commanded when multiple locomotives are present on the same track.

Some model railroads realistically mimic the third rail configurations of their full-sized counterparts; such models may or may not actually draw power from the third rail (most do not).

List of systems


See List of rail transport systems using third rail
List of rail transport systems using third rail

Third rail railways predominantly operate in urban contexts. Notable exceptions are mainline electrics of the former Southern Region of British Railways and a few interurban railways in the US....
 for a complete list.

See also

  • Conduit current collection
    Conduit current collection

    Conduit current collection is a system of electric current collection used by electric trams, where the power supply is carried in a channel under the roadway, rather than located overhead....
  • Fourth rail
    Railway electrification system

    A Railway electrification system supplies Electric potential energy to railway locomotives and multiple units so that they can operate without having an on-board Prime mover ....
  • Ground level power supply
  • List of rail transport systems using third rail
    List of rail transport systems using third rail

    Third rail railways predominantly operate in urban contexts. Notable exceptions are mainline electrics of the former Southern Region of British Railways and a few interurban railways in the US....
  • List of rapid transit systems
    List of rapid transit systems

    There are about 140 rapid transit systems around the world. Such systems are commonly called metros, subways, elevated railways, rapid rail, or underground railways....
  • List of suburban and commuter rail systems
    List of suburban and commuter rail systems

    This is an alphabetical listing of countries and cities that have Regional rail or suburban railways. Unlike rapid transits, these systems usually operate on main line tracks unsegregated from other rail traffic....
 
  • Railway electrification in Great Britain
    Railway electrification in Great Britain

    Railway electrification in Great Britain describes the past and present Railway electrification system used to supply traction current to Rail transport in Great Britain with a chronological record of development, a list of lines using each system, and a history and a technical description of each system....
  • Rubber-tyred metro
    Rubber-tyred metro

    A rubber-tyred metro is a form of rapid transit system that uses a mix of road transport and rail transport technology. The vehicles have wheels with rubber tire which run inside a guideway for traction, as well as traditional railway steel wheels with flanges on steel tracks for guidance....
  • Stud contact system
    Stud contact system

    The Stud Contact System is a once obsolete ground-level power supply system for electric trams. Studs were set in the road at intervals and connected to a buried electric cable by switches operated by magnets on the tramcars....
  • Third rail (model railroading)
    Third rail (model railroading)

    The use of a third rail in model railroading is a technique that is sometimes applied in order to facilitate easier wiring....
  • Third-rail power for trams
    Light rail

    Light rail or light rail transit is a form of urban rail transit public transportation that generally has a lower capacity and lower speed than Passenger_rail_terminology#Heavy_rail and rapid transit systems, but higher capacity and higher speed than street-running tram systems....


  • External links

    • - Paper on Bordeaux' new Tram with street level third rail (by the Transportation Research Board of the National Academies)
    • of the UK 3rd/4th rail design.
    • A short history.