All Topics  
Robert Moog

 
Robert Moog

   Email Print
   Bookmark   Link






 

Robert Moog



 
 
Dr. Robert Arthur Moog ( to rhyme with "rogue") (May 23, 1934 – August 21, 2005) was an American pioneer of electronic music
Electronic music

Electronic music is music that employs electronic musical instruments and electronic music technology in its production. In general a distinction can be made between sound produced using electromechanical means and that produced using electronic technology....
, best known as the inventor
Inventor

An inventor is a person who creates or discovers a new method, form, device or other useful means. The word inventor comes form the latin verb invenire, invent-, to find....
 of the Moog synthesizer
Moog synthesizer

Moog synthesizer may refer to any number of analog synthesizers designed by Dr. Robert Moog or manufactured by Moog Music, and is commonly used as a generic term for analog and digital music synthesisers....
.

tive of New York City
New York City

The City of New York is the List of United States cities by population in the United States, while the New York metropolitan area ranks among the List of urban areas by population....
, Robert Moog attended the Bronx High School of Science
Bronx High School of Science

The Bronx High School of Science is a Specialized High Schools of New York City New York City public high school. Founded in 1938, it is currently located in the Bedford Park, Bronx, New York section of the Bronx....
, graduating in 1952. Moog earned a bachelor's degree
Bachelor's degree

A bachelor's degree is usually an undergraduate academic degree awarded for a course or major that generally lasts for three, four, or in some cases and countries, five or six years....
 in physics from Queens College, New York in 1957, another in electrical engineering
Electrical engineering

Electrical engineering, sometimes referred to as electrical and electronic engineering, is a field of engineering that deals with the study and application of electricity, electronics and electromagnetism....
 from Columbia University
Columbia University

Columbia University in the City of New York , is a private university in the United States and a member of the Ivy League. Columbia's main campus lies in the Morningside Heights, Manhattan neighborhood in the borough of Manhattan, in New York City....
, and a Ph.D.
Doctor of Philosophy

Doctor of Philosophy, abbreviated Ph.D. or PhD for the Latin , meaning "teacher of philosophy", is an postgraduate academic degree awarded by University....
 in engineering physics
Engineering physics

Engineering physics is an academic degree, available mainly at the levels of Bachelor of Science, Master of Science and Doctor of Philosophy Unlike other engineering degrees , EP does not necessarily include a particular branch of science or physics....
 from Cornell University
Cornell University

Cornell University located in Ithaca, New York, USA, is a private university with four Statutory college. Its two medical campuses are in New York City and Education City, Qatar....
. Moog's awards include honorary doctorates from Polytechnic University (New York City
New York City

The City of New York is the List of United States cities by population in the United States, while the New York metropolitan area ranks among the List of urban areas by population....
) and Lycoming College
Lycoming College

Founded in 1812, Lycoming College is located in Williamsport, Pennsylvania. The College enrolls 1500 undergraduate students from over 35 states and 10 foreign countries....
 (Williamsport, Pennsylvania
Williamsport, Pennsylvania

Williamsport is a List of municipalities in Lycoming County, Pennsylvania in and the county seat of Lycoming County, Pennsylvania, Pennsylvania in the United States....
)

During his lifetime, Moog founded two companies for manufacturing electronic musical instruments.






Discussion
Ask a question about 'Robert Moog'
Start a new discussion about 'Robert Moog'
Answer questions from other users
Full Discussion Forum



Encyclopedia


Dr. Robert Arthur Moog ( to rhyme with "rogue") (May 23, 1934 – August 21, 2005) was an American pioneer of electronic music
Electronic music

Electronic music is music that employs electronic musical instruments and electronic music technology in its production. In general a distinction can be made between sound produced using electromechanical means and that produced using electronic technology....
, best known as the inventor
Inventor

An inventor is a person who creates or discovers a new method, form, device or other useful means. The word inventor comes form the latin verb invenire, invent-, to find....
 of the Moog synthesizer
Moog synthesizer

Moog synthesizer may refer to any number of analog synthesizers designed by Dr. Robert Moog or manufactured by Moog Music, and is commonly used as a generic term for analog and digital music synthesisers....
.

Life

A native of New York City
New York City

The City of New York is the List of United States cities by population in the United States, while the New York metropolitan area ranks among the List of urban areas by population....
, Robert Moog attended the Bronx High School of Science
Bronx High School of Science

The Bronx High School of Science is a Specialized High Schools of New York City New York City public high school. Founded in 1938, it is currently located in the Bedford Park, Bronx, New York section of the Bronx....
, graduating in 1952. Moog earned a bachelor's degree
Bachelor's degree

A bachelor's degree is usually an undergraduate academic degree awarded for a course or major that generally lasts for three, four, or in some cases and countries, five or six years....
 in physics from Queens College, New York in 1957, another in electrical engineering
Electrical engineering

Electrical engineering, sometimes referred to as electrical and electronic engineering, is a field of engineering that deals with the study and application of electricity, electronics and electromagnetism....
 from Columbia University
Columbia University

Columbia University in the City of New York , is a private university in the United States and a member of the Ivy League. Columbia's main campus lies in the Morningside Heights, Manhattan neighborhood in the borough of Manhattan, in New York City....
, and a Ph.D.
Doctor of Philosophy

Doctor of Philosophy, abbreviated Ph.D. or PhD for the Latin , meaning "teacher of philosophy", is an postgraduate academic degree awarded by University....
 in engineering physics
Engineering physics

Engineering physics is an academic degree, available mainly at the levels of Bachelor of Science, Master of Science and Doctor of Philosophy Unlike other engineering degrees , EP does not necessarily include a particular branch of science or physics....
 from Cornell University
Cornell University

Cornell University located in Ithaca, New York, USA, is a private university with four Statutory college. Its two medical campuses are in New York City and Education City, Qatar....
. Moog's awards include honorary doctorates from Polytechnic University (New York City
New York City

The City of New York is the List of United States cities by population in the United States, while the New York metropolitan area ranks among the List of urban areas by population....
) and Lycoming College
Lycoming College

Founded in 1812, Lycoming College is located in Williamsport, Pennsylvania. The College enrolls 1500 undergraduate students from over 35 states and 10 foreign countries....
 (Williamsport, Pennsylvania
Williamsport, Pennsylvania

Williamsport is a List of municipalities in Lycoming County, Pennsylvania in and the county seat of Lycoming County, Pennsylvania, Pennsylvania in the United States....
)

During his lifetime, Moog founded two companies for manufacturing electronic musical instruments. Moog also worked as a consultant and vice president for new product research at Kurzweil Music Systems
Kurzweil Music Systems

Kurzweil Music Systems is a company that produces electronic musical instruments for professionals and home users. Founded in 1982 by Raymond Kurzweil, a developer of Optical character recognition for the blindness, the company made use of many of the technologies originally designed for reading machines and adapted them to musical purposes....
 from 1984 to 1988, helping to develop the Kurzweil K2000
Kurzweil K2000

The Kurzweil K2000 is a programmable synthesizer by Kurzweil Music Systems, similar to the Fairlight CMI, Synclavier and the Korg M1.The K2000 features a technology dubbed V.A.S.T., which stands for "Variable Architecture Synthesis Technology", a marketing term for the K2000's DSP-based sound processing system....
. He spent the early 1990s as a research professor of music at the University of North Carolina at Asheville
University of North Carolina at Asheville

The University of North Carolina Asheville is a co-educational, four year, public liberal arts university. The university is also known as UNC Asheville and UNCA....
.

Moog received a Grammy Trustees Award
Grammy Trustees Award

The Grammy Award Trustees Award is awarded by the Recording Academy to "individuals who, during their careers in music, have made significant contributions, other than performance, to the field of recording" ....
 for lifetime achievement in 1970. In 2002, Moog was honored with a Grammy Tech Award, and an honorary doctorate degree from Berklee College of Music
Berklee College of Music

Berklee College of Music, founded in 1945, is an independent music college in Boston, Massachusetts. It has an enrollment of approximately 4,000 students and a 2008 faculty of approximately 500....
.

He gave an enthusiastically-received lecture at the 2004 New Interfaces for Musical Expression
New Interfaces for Musical Expression

New Interfaces for Musical Expression, also known as NIME, is dedicated to scientific research on the development of new technologies for musical expression and artistic performance....
 (NIME-04), held in Hamamatsu
Hamamatsu, Shizuoka

is a cities of Japan located in western Shizuoka Prefecture, Japan, and is the largest city in the prefecture. On July 1, 2005, the city merged with 11 surrounding cities and towns....
, Japan's "City of Musical Instruments", in June, 2004. Moog was the inspiration behind the 2004 film Moog
Moog (film)

Moog is a 2004 in film by Hans Fjellestad about Electronic musical instrument pioneer Dr. Robert Moog. The film features scenes of Dr. Moog interacting with various musical artists who view Moog as an influential figure in the history of electronic music....
.

Moog's first wife was Shirleigh Moog (née Shirley May Leigh) a grammar school teacher whom he married in 1958. The couple had 3 daughters (Laura Moog Lanier, Michelle Moog-Koussa, Renee Moog) and one son (Matthew Moog) before their divorce. Moog was married to his second wife Ileana Grams, a philosophy professor, for nine years until his death. Moog's stepdaughter, Miranda Richmond, is Grams' daughter from a previous marriage. Moog also had five grandchildren.

Robert Moog was diagnosed with a glioblastoma multiforme
Glioblastoma multiforme

Glioblastoma multiforme is the most common and most aggressive type of primary brain tumor in humans, accounting for 52% of all primary brain tumor cases and 20% of all intracranial tumors....
 brain tumor on April 28, 2005. Nearly four months later, Moog died at the age of 71 in Asheville
Asheville, North Carolina

Asheville is a city in and the county seat of Buncombe County, North Carolina, North Carolina, United States. The population was 68,889 at the United States Census, 2000....
, North Carolina
North Carolina

North Carolina is a U.S. state located on the Atlantic Seaboard in the southeastern United States. The state borders South Carolina and Georgia to the south, Tennessee to the west and Virginia to the north....
 on August 21, 2005. His end of life journey was captured using CaringBridge
CaringBridge

CaringBridge is a charitable nonprofit organization offering free personalized websites to people facing a serious medical condition, hospitalization, undergoing medical treatment and/or recovering from a significant accident, illness, injury or procedure....
. The Bob Moog Foundation
Bob Moog Foundation

The Bob Moog Memorial Foundation was founded after the death of Bob Moog in 2005. His family established the foundation, dedicated to the advancement of electronic music in his memory....
 was created as a memorial, with the aim of continuing his life's work of developing electronic music.

Development of the Moog synthesizer

The Moog synthesizer
Synthesizer

A synthesizer is an electronic instrument capable of producing a variety of sounds by generating and combining signals of different frequency....
 was one of the first widely used electronic musical instruments. Early developmental work on the components of the synthesizer occurred at the Columbia-Princeton Electronic Music Center, now the Computer Music Center
Computer Music Center

The Computer Music Center at Columbia University is the oldest center for electronic music and computer music research in the United States. The Center was founded in the 1950s as the Columbia-Princeton Electronic Music Center....
. While there, Moog developed the voltage controlled oscillators, ADSR envelope generators, and other synthesizer modules with composer Herbert Deutsch.

Moog created the first voltage-controlled subtractive synthesizer to utilize a keyboard as a controller and demonstrated it at the AES
Audio Engineering Society

Established in 1948, the Audio Engineering Society draws its membership from amongst engineers, scientists, manufacturers and other organizations and individuals with an interest or involvement in the professional audio industry....
 convention in 1964. In 1966, Moog filed a patent application for his unique low-pass filter
Low-pass filter

A low-pass filter is a electronic filter that passes low-frequency signal but attenuates signals with frequencies higher than the cutoff frequency....
 , which issued in October 1969. He held several dozen patents.

Robert Moog employed his theremin
Theremin

The theremin is an early electronic musical instrument controlled without contact from the player. It is named after its Russian inventor, Professor Leon Theremin, who patented the device in 1928....
 company (R. A. Moog Co., which would later become Moog Music) to manufacture and market his synthesizers. Unlike the few other 1960s synthesizer manufacturers, Moog shipped a piano-style keyboard
Musical keyboard

A musical keyboard is the set of adjacent depressible levers or keys on a musical instrument, particularly the piano. Keyboards typically contain keys for playing the twelve notes of the Western musical scale, with a combination of larger, longer keys and smaller, shorter keys that repeats at the interval of an octave....
 as the standard user interface to his synthesizers. Moog also established standards for analog synthesizer control interfacing, with a logarithmic one volt-per-octave pitch control and a separate pulse triggering signal.

The first Moog instruments were modular synthesizer
Modular synthesizer

The modular synthesizer is a type of synthesizer consisting of separate specialized modules connected by wires to create a so-called patch . Every output generates a signal - an electric voltage of variable strength....
s. In 1971 Moog Music began production of the Minimoog
Minimoog

The Minimoog is a monophonic analog synthesizer, invented by Bill Hemsath and Robert Moog. Released in 1971 by the original Moog Music, it was among the first widely available, portable and relatively affordable synthesizers....
 Model D which was among the first widely available, portable and relatively affordable synthesizers.

One of Moog's earliest musical customers was Wendy Carlos
Wendy Carlos

Wendy Carlos is an United States composer and electronic musician. She gained fame in the late 1960s for playing on the Moog synthesizer, which was a relatively new and unknown instrument at the time....
 whom he credits with providing feedback that was valuable to the further development of Moog synthesizers. Through his involvement in electronic music, Moog developed close professional relationships with artists such as Don Buchla
Don Buchla

Don Buchla is a pioneer in the field of sound synthesizers, releasing his first units months after Robert Moog's first synthesizers. However, his instrument was arguably designed before Moog's....
, Keith Emerson
Keith Emerson

Keith Noel Emerson is a British keyboard player and composer. Formerly a member of the Keith Emerson Trio, John Brown's Bodies, The T-Bones, V.I.P.s, P.P....
, Rick Wakeman
Rick Wakeman

Richard Christopher Wakeman is an England keyboard player best known as the keyboardist for progressive rock group Yes . Originally a classically trained pianist, he was a pioneer in the use of electronic keyboards and in the use of a rock band in combination with orchestra and choir....
, John Cage
John Cage

John Milton Cage Jr. was an American composer. A pioneer of Aleatoric music, electronic music and Extended technique, Cage was one of the leading figures of the post-war avant-garde and, in the opinion of many, the most influential American composer of the 20th century....
, Gershon Kingsley
Gershon Kingsley

Gershon Kingsley, is a contemporary Germany-born United States composer most famous for composing the early electronic pop instrumental song Popcorn ....
, Clara Rockmore
Clara Rockmore

Clara Rockmore is generally considered to be the most accomplished performer ever of the theremin electronic musical instrument....
, and Pamelia Kurstin
Pamelia Kurstin

Pamelia Kurstin is a world-renowned thereminist who has played and recorded with such prestigious artists as David Byrne , B?la Fleck and the Flecktones, and Ulver and has performed on the television show Saturday Night Live....
. In a 2000 interview, Moog said "I'm an engineer. I see myself as a toolmaker and the musicians are my customers. They use my tools."

R.A. Moog Co. and Moog Music

In 1953 at age 19, Robert Moog founded his first company, R.A. Moog Co., to manufacture theremin kits. During the 1960s, the company was employed to build modular synthesizers
Moog modular synthesizer

Moog modular synthesizer refers to any of a number of monophonic analog modular synthesizers designed by the late Electronic musical instrument pioneer Dr....
 based on Moog's designs.

In 1972 Moog changed the company's name to Moog Music
Moog Music

Moog Music is an United States of America company based in Asheville, North Carolina which manufactures electronic musical instruments. The current Moog Music is the second company to trade under that name....
. Throughout the 1970s, Moog Music went through various changes of ownership, eventually being bought out by musical instrument manufacturer Norlin. Poor management and marketing led to Moog's departure from his own company in 1977.

In 1978 after leaving his namesake firm, Moog started making electronic musical instruments again with a new company, Big Briar. Their first specialty was theremins, but by 1999 the company expanded to produce a line of analog effects pedals called moogerfooger
Moogerfooger

moogerfooger is the trademark for a series of Analog signal effects pedals manufactured by Moog Music. There are currently five different pedals produced, however one of these models is designed for processing Analog signal processing rather than Audio signal processing signal....
s. In 1999, Moog partnered with Bomb Factory
Bomb Factory

Bomb Factory is a recording studio and manufacturer of music plugins based in Los Angeles, California....
 to co-develop the first digital effects based on Moog technology in the form of plugin
Plugin

In computing, a plug-in consists of a computer program that interacts with a host application software to provide a certain, usually very specific, function "on demand"....
s for Pro Tools
Pro Tools

Pro Tools is a Digital Audio Workstation platformfor Mac OS and Microsoft Windows operating systems, developed and manufactured by Digidesign, a division of Avid Technology....
 software.

Despite Moog Music's closing in 1993, Robert Moog did not have the rights to market products using his own name throughout the 1990s. Big Briar acquired the rights to use the Moog Music name in 2002 after a legal battle with Don Martin who had previously bought the rights to the name Moog Music. At the same time, Moog designed a new version of the Minimoog called the Minimoog Voyager
Minimoog Voyager

The Minimoog Voyager or Voyager is a monophonic analog synthesizer, designed by Robert Moog and released in 2002 by Moog Music. The Voyager was modeled after the classic Minimoog synthesizer that was popular in the 1970s....
. The Voyager includes nearly all of the features of the original Model D in addition to numerous modern features.

Theremin

Robert Moog constructed his own theremin
Theremin

The theremin is an early electronic musical instrument controlled without contact from the player. It is named after its Russian inventor, Professor Leon Theremin, who patented the device in 1928....
 as early as 1949. Later he described a theremin in the hobbyist magazine Electronics World and offered a kit of parts for the construction of the Electronic World's Theremin, which became very successful. In the late 1980s Moog repaired the original theremin of Clara Rockmore
Clara Rockmore

Clara Rockmore is generally considered to be the most accomplished performer ever of the theremin electronic musical instrument....
, an accomplishment which he considered a high point of his professional career. He also produced, in collaboration with first wife Shirleigh Moog, Mrs. Rockmore's album, The Art of the Theremin
The Art of the Theremin

The Art of the Theremin is the first official album by Clara Rockmore, released in 1977 by Delos International....
. Dr. Moog was a principal interview subject in the award-winning documentary film, THEREMIN- An Electronic Odyssey, the success of which led to a revival of interest in the theremin. Moog Music went back to its roots and once again began manufacturing theremins. Thousands have been sold to date and are used by both professional and amateur musicians around the globe. In 1996 he published another do-it-yourself theremin guide. Today, Moog Music is the leading manufacturer of performance-quality theremins.

Pronunciation

The surname Moog is one of the most divergently pronounced names in popular culture. The following interview excerpt reveals Robert Moog's preferred pronunciation:

— Reviewer: First off: Does your name rhyme with "vogue" or is like a cow’s "moo" plus a "G" at the end?
— Dr. Robert Moog: It rhymes with vogue. That is the usual German pronunciation. My father's grandfather came from Marburg
Marburg

Marburg is a city in Hesse, Germany, on the River Lahn. It is the main town of the Marburg-Biedenkopf district. Its population is 78,701, and its geographical position is ....
, Germany
Germany

Germany , officially the Federal Republic of Germany , is a country in Central Europe. It is bordered to the north by the North Sea, Denmark, and the Baltic Sea; to the east by Poland and the Czech Republic; to the south by Austria and Switzerland; and to the west by France, Luxembourg, Belgium, and the Netherlands....
. I like the way that pronunciation sounds better than the way the cow's "moo-g" sounds.


(Note that the English sound prescribed here is a loose approximation of the German pronunciation of the surname Moog , which has a monophthong
Monophthong

A monophthong is a "pure" vowel sound, one whose articulation at both beginning and end is relatively fixed, and which does not semivowel towards a new position of articulation; compare diphthong....
 and devoiced
Final obstruent devoicing

Final obstruent devoicing or terminal devoicing is a systematic phonology process occurring in languages such as German language, Dutch language, Polish language, and Russian language, among others....
 final consonant.)

In a deleted scene from the DVD version of the documentary Moog, Moog describes the three pronunciations of the name Moog: the original, Dutch pronunciation , which he believes would be too demanding of English speakers, the preferred "German" pronunciation , and the more common pronunciation in English-speaking countries . Moog reveals that some of his family members prefer the English pronunciation, while others, including himself (and his wife) prefer the Anglo-German pronunciation.

See also

  • Bob Moog Foundation
    Bob Moog Foundation

    The Bob Moog Memorial Foundation was founded after the death of Bob Moog in 2005. His family established the foundation, dedicated to the advancement of electronic music in his memory....
  • Moog (film)
    Moog (film)

    Moog is a 2004 in film by Hans Fjellestad about Electronic musical instrument pioneer Dr. Robert Moog. The film features scenes of Dr. Moog interacting with various musical artists who view Moog as an influential figure in the history of electronic music....
  • Moog Music
    Moog Music

    Moog Music is an United States of America company based in Asheville, North Carolina which manufactures electronic musical instruments. The current Moog Music is the second company to trade under that name....
  • Moog synthesizer
    Moog synthesizer

    Moog synthesizer may refer to any number of analog synthesizers designed by Dr. Robert Moog or manufactured by Moog Music, and is commonly used as a generic term for analog and digital music synthesisers....
  • List of Moog synthesizer players
  • Electronic music
    Electronic music

    Electronic music is music that employs electronic musical instruments and electronic music technology in its production. In general a distinction can be made between sound produced using electromechanical means and that produced using electronic technology....
  • Raymond Scott
    Raymond Scott

    Raymond Scott , was an American composer, band leader, pianist, engineer, recording studio maverick, and electronic instrument inventor. He was born in Brooklyn, New York to a family of Russian-Jewish immigrants....
  • Léon Theremin
    Léon Theremin

    L?on Theremin was a Russian inventor. He is most famous for his invention of the theremin, one of the first electronic musical instruments. He is also the inventor of interlace, a technique of improving the picture quality of a video signal, widely used in video and television technology....
  • Bruce Haack
    Bruce Haack

    Bruce Clinton Haack was a musician and composer, and a pioneer within the realm of electronic music. He was born in Alberta, Canada....
  • List of notable brain tumor patients
    List of notable brain tumor patients

    This article provides a list of notable people who had a primary or metastasis brain tumor at some point in their lives, as confirmed by public information....


Footnotes


External links

  • more samples –
  • li
  • illustrated history of company and products
Interviews and articles
  • (the unaddressed letter and the UJT-Relay sequencer invention)
  • on format mp3
  • on format mp3
  • in New Scientist
    New Scientist

    New Scientist is a liberal weekly international science magazine and website covering recent developments in science and technology for a general English language-speaking audience....
     magazine
  • with Moog from 2004 on WNYC
    WNYC

    WNYC is a public broadcasting radio station and formerly a city owned television station in New York City, New York. Broadcasting from lower Manhattan, it is a member station of National Public Radio and carries a mixed news and varied music format on two radio frequencies....
     in RealAudio
    RealAudio

    RealAudio is a Proprietary format audio format developed by RealNetworks. It uses a variety of audio codecs, ranging from low-bitrate formats that can be used over dialup modems, to high-fidelity formats for music....
     format. Moog portion begins 30 minutes into program.
  • discussing his design philosophy and future of synthesis
Patents
Obituaries
  • in BBC News
    BBC News

    BBC News, formerly BBC News and Current Affairs, is the department within the BBC responsible for the corporation's news-gathering and production of news programmes on BBC television, radio and online....
  • in BBC News
    BBC News

    BBC News, formerly BBC News and Current Affairs, is the department within the BBC responsible for the corporation's news-gathering and production of news programmes on BBC television, radio and online....
  • in Asheville Citizen-Times
    Asheville Citizen-Times

    The Asheville Citizen-Times is a Gannett newspaper based in Asheville, North Carolina, U.S.A.. Founded in 1870 as a weekly, the Citizen-Times became a daily newspaper in 1885....
  • in CNN
    CNN

    Cable News Network, almost always referred to by its initialism CNN, is a major US Cable News Network founded in 1980 by Ted Turner. Upon its launch, CNN was the first station to provide 24-hour television news coverage, and the first all-news television network in the United States....
  • in Los Angeles Times
    Los Angeles Times

    The Los Angeles Times is a daily newspaper published in Los Angeles, California and distributed throughout the Western United States. It is the second-largest metropolitan newspaper in the United States and the fourth-most widely distributed newspaper in the United States....
  • in The New York Times (May require free registration to access)
  • in The Economist
    The Economist

    The Economist is an English-language weekly news and international relations publication owned by The Economist Newspaper Ltd. and edited in London....
  • in Mix Magazine
  • in The Times
    The Times

    The Times is a daily national newspaper published in the United Kingdom since 1785 when it was known as The Daily Universal Register.The Times and its sister paper The Sunday Times are published by Times Newspapers Limited, a subsidiary of News International....
Tributes
  • (The New York Times)