|
|
|
|
Phonological history of English low back vowels
|
| |
|
| |
Father-bother merger The father-bother merger is a merger of the Early Modern English vowels and that occurs in almost all varieties of North American English (exceptions are accents in northeastern New England, such as the Boston accent, and in New York City). In those accents with the merger father and bother rhyme, and Kahn and con are homophonous as . Unrounding of EME is found also in Norwich, the West Country, the West Midlands and in Hiberno-English, but apparently with no phonemic merger.
Lot-cloth split The lot-cloth split is the result of a late seventeenth-century sound change that lengthened to before voiceless fricatives, and also before in the word gone. In some accents, the lengthened was raised, merging with the of words like thought. Words that entered the language later, or words that were used more in writing than speech, were often exempt from the lengthening, so that joss and Goth still have the short vowel.
As a result of the lengthening and raising, in the above-mentioned accents cross rhymes with sauce, and soft and cloth also have the vowel . Accents affected by this change include American English and, originally, RP, although today words of this group almost always have short in RP.
The lengthening and raising generally happened before the fricatives , and . In American English the raising was extended to the environment before and in a few words to the environment before as well, giving pronunciations like for long, for chocolate, and for dog. Obviously, in accents of American English that are subject to the cot-caught merger, there is no difference between words that did and those that did not undergo the change.
In the varieties of American English that have the lot-cloth split, many words vary as to whether or not they have the cloth vowel. For example, words that end in -og like frog, hog, fog, log, bog etc. have the cloth vowel in some accents with the lot-cloth split and the lot vowel in other accents with the split.
The word gone usually has the cloth vowel in accents with the lot-cloth split, but has the lot vowel in accents of New York and New Jersey which have the split.
The word on is pronounced with the lot vowel in the North, and with the cloth vowel in the Midland, Mid-Atlantic and South.
Cot-caught merger
The cot-caught merger (also known as the low back merger) is a phonemic merger, a sound change, that occurs in some varieties of English. The merger occurs in some accents of Scottish English and to some extent in Mid Ulster English but is best known as a phenomenon of many varieties of North American English.
The sound change causes the vowel in caught, talk, and small to be pronounced like the vowel in cot, rock, and doll, so that cot and caught, for example, become homophones, and the two vowels merge into a single phoneme. The presence of the merger and its absence are both found in many different regions of the continent, and in both urban and rural environments.
The symbols traditionally used to transcribe the vowels in the words cot and caught as spoken in American English are open back unrounded vowel and open-mid back rounded vowel. For many American speakers, especially in the Inland North region, is actually fronted to , and, to a lesser extent, is lowered to . The precise phonetic value of the merged vowel varies from region to region, as do the phonetic values of the unmerged vowels in regions where the merger has not occurred.
According to Labov, Ash, and Boberg, the merger does not generally occur in the southern United States (with exceptions), along the American side of the Great Lakes region, or in the "Northeast Corridor" extended metropolitan region from New York City to Baltimore. It is very widespread across Canada, the Boston, Massachusetts area (see Boston accent) and northeastern New England,
the Pittsburgh area (see Pittsburghese), and is also heard throughout the western U.S. The latter seems to be the source of its introduction into the Midwest as it appears to be spreading eastward. A recent survey directed by William Labov of the University of Pennsylvania has shown that the merger can be found today among younger generations (roughly people under 40) in Kansas, Nebraska, and the Dakotas. It is also heard across much of Minnesota, Iowa, and Missouri. Similarly, the merger affects central portions of Illinois, Indiana, and Ohio, though its appearance in these areas may represent a westward expansion of the change from Pennsylvania. The distribution of the merger is complex, even without taking into account the mobility of the American population; there are pockets of speakers with the merger in areas that lack it, and vice versa. There are areas where the merger has only partially occurred, or is in a state of transition. Labov et al.'s research is based on telephone surveys with subjects who grew up in the city where they lived at the time of the interview. The 2003 Harvard Dialect Survey, in which subjects did not necessarily grow up in the place they identified as the source of their dialect features, indicates that there are speakers of both merging and contrast-preserving accents throughout the country, though the basic isoglosses are almost identical to those revealed by Labov's 1996 telephone survey. Both surveys indicate that approximately 60% of American English speakers preserve the contrast, while approximately 40% make the merger.
For merged speakers in Canada and most of the United States, the two sounds and are allophones; they often do not perceive differences in their usage, hear neither of them as a separate phoneme, and hear the distinct vowels used by speakers whose dialects do distinguish them as variations on the same vowel. They hear the broad A of British Received Pronunciation as the same, single vowel sound. But in Received Pronunciation, there are three sounds distinguished: the long of cart, the long of caught, and the short rounded of cot.
Speakers with the merger in northeastern New England still maintain a phonemic distinction between a fronted and unrounded and a back and usually rounded , because in northeastern New England (unlike in Canada and the Western United States), the cot-caught merger occurred without the father-bother merger. Thus, although northeastern New Englanders pronounce both cot and caught as , they pronounce cart as .
Labov et al. also reveal that about 15% of respondents have the merger before but not before , so that Don and Dawn are homophonous, but cot and caught are not. A much smaller group (about 4%) has the reverse situation: cot and caught are homophonous but Don and Dawn are distinct.
Bud-bird mergerThe bud-bird merger is a merger of // and // occurring for some speakers of Jamaican English making bud and bird homonyms as /bd/.
The conversion of // to [] or [] is also found in places scattered around England and Scotland. Some speakers, mostly rural, in the area from London to Norfolk exhibit this conversion, mainly before voiceless fricatives. This gives pronunciation like first [fst] and worse [ws]. The word cuss appears to derive from the application of this sound change to the word curse.
The word work is often heard with pronunciations like [wk] in Lancashire, Derbyshire and South Yorkshire.
See also
External links-
-
-
-
- , which discusses the "short-o" configuration of various American accents
|
| |
|
|
