Encyclopedia
MPEG-1 Audio Layer 3, more commonly referred to as
MP3, is a popular digital audio encoding and
lossy compression format, designed to greatly reduce the amount of data required to represent audio, yet still sound like a faithful reproduction of the original uncompressed audio to most listeners. It was invented by a team of European engineers who worked in the framework of the EUREKA 147 DAB digital radio research program, and it became an
ISO/IEC standard in 1991.
Overview
MP3 is an audio-specific compression format. It provides a representation of
pulse-code modulation-encoded audio in much less space than straightforward methods, by using psychoacoustic models to discard components less audible to human hearing, and recording the remaining information in an efficient manner. Similar principles are used by
JPEG, a lossy image compression format.
The MP3 format uses a hybrid transformation to transform a time domain signal into a frequency domain signal:
- 32-band polyphase quadrature filter
- 36 or 12 tap MDCT; size can be selected independently for sub-bands 0...1 and 2...31
- Aliasing reduction postprocessing
MP3 audio can be compressed with different bit rates, providing a range of tradeoffs between data size and sound quality.
The MPEG specifications support AAC from MPEG-4 as MP3's successor, although other new audio formats have also achieved similar usage levels. However, MP3's extreme popularity makes it secure in its dominant position for the near future, with support from a huge range of software and hardware, including portable
MP3 players and even some DVD and CD players. The large MP3 collections that many individuals have amassed will also ensure its longevity, in the same way as with any physical medium.
History
Development
MPEG-1 Audio Layer 2 encoding began as the Digital Audio Broadcast project managed by Egon Meier-Engelen of the
Deutsche Forschungs- und Versuchsanstalt für Luft- und Raumfahrt in
Germany. This project was financed by the European Union as a part of the EUREKA research program where it was commonly known as EU-147. EU-147 ran from 1987 to 1994.
In 1991, there were two proposals available: Musicam , and ASPEC . The Musicam technique, as proposed by
Philips , CCETT and Institut für Rundfunktechnik was chosen due to its simplicity and error robustness, as well as its low computational power associated to the encoding of high quality compressed audio. The Musicam format, based on sub-band encoding, was a key to settle the basis of the MPEG Audio compression format . Its technology and ideas were fully incorporated into the definition of ISO MPEG Audio Layer I and Layer II and further on of the Layer III format. Under the chairmanship of Professor Mussmann the editing of the standard was made under the responsibilities of Leon van de Kerkhof and Gerhard Stoll .
A working group consisting of Leon Van de Kerkhof , Gerhard Stoll , Yves-François Dehery , Karlheinz Brandenburg took ideas from Musicam and ASPEC, added some of their own ideas and created MP3, which was designed to achieve the same quality at 128 kbit/s as MP2 at 192 kbit/s.
All algorithms were approved in 1991, finalized in 1992 as part of MPEG-1, the first standard suite by MPEG, which resulted in the international standard
ISO/IEC 11172-3, published in 1993. Further work on MPEG audio was finalized in 1994 as part of the second suite of MPEG standards, MPEG-2, more formally known as international standard
ISO/IEC 13818-3, originally published in 1995.
Compression efficiency of encoders is typically defined by the bit rate because compression rate depends on the bit depth and sampling rate of the input signal. Nevertheless, there are often published compression rates that use the
CD parameters as references . Sometimes the
Digital Audio Tape SP parameters are used . Compression ratios with this reference are higher, which demonstrates the problem of the term
compression ratio for lossy encoders.
Karlheinz Brandenburg used a CD recording of
Suzanne Vega's song "
Tom's Diner" to assess the MP3 compression algorithm. This song was chosen because of its softness and simplicity, making it easier to hear imperfections in the compression format during playbacks. Some have taken to jokingly refer to Suzanne Vega as "The mother of MP3". Some more serious and critical audio excerpts were taken from the EBU V3/SQAM reference compact disc and have been used by professional sound engineers to assess the subjective quality of the MPEG Audio formats.
MP3 goes public
A reference simulation software implementation, written in the C language and known as ISO 11172-5, was developed by the members of the ISO MPEG Audio committee in order to produce bit compliant MPEG Audio files . Working in non real time on a number of operating systems, it was able to demonstrate the first real time hardware decoding of compressed audio. Some other real time implementation of MPEG Audio encoders were available for the purpose of digital broadcasting towards consumer receivers and set top boxes.
Later, on July 7 1994 the Fraunhofer Society released the first software MP3 encoder called l3enc. The filename extension
.mp3 was chosen by the Fraunhofer team on July 14, 1995 . With the first real-time software MP3 player
Winplay3 many people were able to encode and playback MP3 files on their PCs. Because of the relatively small
hard drives back in that time the technology was essential to store non-instrument based music for listening pleasure on a computer.
MP2, MP3 and the Internet
In October 1993, MP2 files appeared on the
Internet and were often played back using the
Xing MPEG Audio Player, and later in a program for
Unix by Tobias Bading called MAPlay, which was initially released on February 22, 1994 .
Initially the only encoder available for MP2 production was the Xing Encoder, accompanied by the program CDDA2WAV, a CD ripper that transforms CD audio tracks to Waveform Audio Files.
The Internet Underground Music Archive is generally recognized as the start of the on-line music revolution. IUMA was the Internet's first high-fidelity music web site, hosting thousands of authorized MP2 recordings before MP3 or the web was popularized.
In the first half of 1995 through the late
1990s, MP3 files began flourishing on the
Internet. MP3 popularity was mostly due to, and interchangeable with, the successes of companies and software packages like Nullsoft's
Winamp , mpg123, and
Napster . Those programs made it very easy for the average user to playback, create, share, and collect MP3s.
Controversies regarding peer-to-peer
file sharing of MP3 files have spread widely in recent years — largely because high compression enables sharing of files that would otherwise be too large and cumbersome to share. Some major record companies reacted by filing a
lawsuit against Napster, due to the vastly increased spread of MP3s through the Internet, to protect their
copyrights .
Commercial online music distribution services usually prefer other/proprietary music file formats that support
Digital Rights Management to control and restrict the use of digital music. The use of formats that support DRM is in an attempt to prevent copyright infringement of
copyright protected materials, but methods exist to defeat most protection schemes.
Encoding of MP3 audio
The MPEG-1 standard does not include a precise specification for an MP3 encoder.
The decoding algorithm and file format, as a contrast, are well defined.
Implementers of the standard were supposed to devise their own algorithms suitable for removing parts of the information in the raw audio . During encoding 576 time domain samples are taken and are transformed to 576 frequency domain samples. If there is a transient 192 samples are taken instead of 576. This is done to limit the temporal spread of quantization noise accompanying the transient.
This is the domain of psychoacoustics: the study of subjective human perception of sounds.
As a result, there are many different MP3 encoders available, each producing files of differing quality.
Comparisons are widely available, so it is easy for a prospective user of an encoder to research the best choice.
It must be kept in mind that an encoder that is proficient at encoding at higher bitrates is not necessarily as good at other, lower bitrates.
Decoding of MP3 audio
Decoding, on the other hand, is carefully defined in the standard.
Most
decoders are "bitstream compliant", meaning that the decompressed output they produce from a given MP3 file will be the same as the output specified mathematically in the .
The MP3 file has a standard format which is a frame consisting of 384, 576, or 1152 samples and all the frames have associated header information
and side information . The header and side information help the decoder to decode the associated Huffman encoded data correctly.
Therefore, for the most part, comparison of decoders is almost exclusively based on how computationally efficient they are .
Bit rate
The bit rate is variable for MP3 files. The general rule is that more information is included from the original sound file when a higher bit rate is used, and thus the higher the quality during playback. In the early days of MP3 encoding, a fixed bit rate was used for the entire file.
Bit rates available in MPEG-1 Layer 3 are 32, 40, 48, 56, 64, 80, 96, 112, 128, 160, 192, 224, 256 and 320 kbit/s, and the available sampling frequencies are 32, 44.1 and 48 kHz. 44.1 kHz is almost always used , and 128 kbit/s has become the de facto "good enough" standard, although 192 kbit/s is becoming increasingly popular over peer-to-peer
file sharing networks. MPEG-2 and [the non-official] MPEG-2.5 includes some additional bit rates: 8, 16, 24, 32, 40, 48, 56, 64, 80, 96, 112, 128, 144, 160 kbit/s while providing lower sampling frequencies .
Variable bit rates are also possible. Audio in MP3 files is divided into frames , so it is possible to change the bit rate dynamically as the file is encoded . This technique makes it possible to use more bits for parts of the sound with higher dynamics and fewer bits for parts with lower dynamics, further increasing quality and decreasing storage space. This method compares to a sound activated tape recorder that reduces tape consumption by not recording silence. Some encoders utilize this technique to a great extent.
Non-standard bitrates up to 640 kbit/s can be achieved with the
LAME encoder and the --freeformat option, however few MP3 players can play those files.
Quality of MP3 audio
Because MP3 is a
lossy format, it is able to provide a number of different options for its "bit rate" — that is, the number of bits of encoded data that are used to represent each second of audio. Typically, rates chosen are between 128 and 320
kilobit per second. By contrast, uncompressed audio as stored on a
compact disc has a bit rate of 1411.2 kbit/s .
MP3 files encoded with a lower bit rate will generally play back at a lower quality. With too low a bit rate, "
compression artifacts" may appear in the reproduction. A good demonstration of compression artifacts is provided by the sound of applause: it is hard to compress because of its randomness and sharp attacks. Therefore compression artifacts are audible as ringing or pre-echo.
As well as the bit rate of the encoded file, the quality of MP3 files depends on the quality of the encoder and the difficulty of the signal being encoded. As the MP3 standard allows quite a bit of freedom with encoding algorithms, different encoders may feature quite different quality, even when targeting similar bitrates. As an example, in a public collective test featuring two different MP3 encoders at about 128kbps, one scored 3.66 on a 1-5 scale, while the other scored only 2.22.
Quality is heavily dependent on the choice of encoder and encoding parameters. While quality around 128kbps was somewhere between annoying and acceptable with older encoders, modern MP3 encoders can provide very good quality at those bitrates , not statistically different from quality provided by AAC, the technical successor of MP3. However, in 1998, MP3 at 128kbps was only providing quality equivalent to AAC-LC at 96kbps and MP2 at 192kbps .
The transparency threshold of MP3 can be estimated to be at about 190kbps with good encoders. However, due to design limitations of the MP3 format, a few specific samples cannot be transparently encoded, even at those high bitrates.
At lower bitrates, the quality of MP3 quickly degrades, and is way behind AAC quality at 32kbps, as demonstrated by a collective listening test .
It is also important to note that perceived quality can be influenced by listening environment , listener attention, and listener training.
MP3 File Structure
An MP3 file is made up of multiple MP3 frames which consist of the MP3 header and the MP3 data. This sequence of frames is called an Elementary stream. Frames are independent items: one can cut the frames from a file and an MP3 player would be able to play it. The MP3 data is the actual audio payload. The diagram shows that the MP3 header consists of a sync word which is used to identify the beginning of a valid frame. This is followed by a bit indicating that this is the MPEG standard and two bits that indicate that layer 3 is being used, hence MPEG-1 Audio Layer 3 or MP3. After this, the values will differ depending on the MP3 file. The range of values for each section of the header along with the specification of the header is defined by
ISO/IEC 11172-3. Most MP3 files today contain ID3 metadata which precedes or follows the MP3 frames; this is also shown in the diagram.
Design limitations of MP3
There are several limitations inherent to the MP3 format that cannot be overcome by using a better encoder.
Newer audio compression formats such as
Vorbis and
AAC no longer have these limitations.
In technical terms, MP3 is limited in the following ways:
- Bitrate is limited to a maximum of 320 kbit/s
- Time resolution can be too low for highly transient signals, causing some smearing of percussive sounds
- Frequency resolution is limited by the small long block window size, decreasing coding efficiency
- No scale factor band for frequencies above 15.5/15.8 kHz
- Joint stereo is done on a frame-to-frame basis
- Encoder/decoder overall delay is not defined, which means lack of official provision for gapless playback. However, some encoders such as LAME can attach additional metadata that will allow players that are aware of it to deliver gapless playback.
Nevertheless, a well-tuned MP3 encoder can perform competitively even with these restrictions.
ID3 and other tags
- Main articles: ID3 and APEv2 tag
A "tag" in a compressed audio file, is a section of the file that contains metadata such as the title, artist, album, track number or other information about the file's contents.
As of 2006, the most widespread standard tag formats are ID3v1 and ID3v2, and the more recently introduced APEv2.
APEv2 was originally developed for the MPC file format . APEv2 can coexist with ID3 tags in the same file, but it can also be used by itself.
Tag editing functionality is often built-in to MP3 players and editors, but there also exist tag editors dedicated to the purpose.
Volume normalization
As
compact discs and other various sources are recorded and mastered at different volumes, it is useful to store volume information about a file in the tag so that at playback time, the volume can be dynamically adjusted.
A few standards for encoding the gain of an MP3 file have been proposed.
The idea is to normalize the average volume of audio files, so that the volume does not change between consecutive tracks. This should not be confused with dynamic range compression which is a form of normalization used in audio mastering.
The most popular and widely used solution for storing replay gain is known simply as "Replay Gain".
Typically, the average volume and clipping information about audio track is stored in the metadata tag.
Licensing and patent issues
Thomson Consumer Electronics controls licensing of the in countries that recognize
software patents, including the
United States and
Japan, but not EU countries. Thomson has been actively enforcing these patents. Thomson has been granted
software patents in EU countries and by the European Patent Office , but it is unclear whether they would be enforced by courts there. See Software patents under the European Patent Convention.
For current information about Thomson's patent portfolio and licensing terms and fees see their website .
In September 1998, the Fraunhofer Institute sent a letter to several developers of MP3 software stating that a license was required to "distribute and/or sell decoders and/or encoders". The letter claimed that unlicensed products "infringe the patent rights of Fraunhofer and THOMSON. To make, sell and/or distribute products using the [MPEG Layer-3] standard and thus our patents, you need to obtain a license under these patents from us."
These patent issues significantly slowed the development of unlicensed MP3 software and led to increased focus on creating and popularizing alternatives such as WMA and
Ogg Vorbis.
Microsoft, the makers of the Windows operating system, chose to move away from MP3 to their own proprietary Windows Media formats to avoid the licensing issues associated with the patents. Until the key patents expire, unlicensed encoders and players appear to be illegal in countries that recognize software patents.
In spite of the patent restrictions, the perpetuation of the MP3 format continues; the reasons for this appear to be the
network effects caused by:
- familiarity with the format,
- the fact that these alternatives do not generally provide a clear advantage over MP3,
- the large quantity of music now available in the MP3 format,
- the wide variety of existing software and hardware that takes advantage of the file format,
- the lack of DRM-protection technology, which makes MP3 files easy to edit, copy and distribute over networks,
- the majority of home users not knowing or not caring about the software patent controversy, which is in general irrelevant to their choice of the MP3 format for personal use.
Additionally, patent holders declined to enforce license fees on open source decoders, allowing many free MP3 decoders to develop. Furthermore, while attempts have been made to discourage distribution of encoder binaries, Thomson has stated that individuals using free MP3 encoders are not required to pay fees. Thus while patent fees have been an issue for companies attempting to use MP3, they have not meaningfully impacted users, allowing the format to grow in popularity.
Sisvel S.p.A. and its US subsidiary Audio MPEG, Inc. previously sued Thomson for patent infringement on MP3 technology, but those disputes were resolved in November 2005 with Sisvel granting Thomson a license to their patents. Motorola also recently signed with Audio MPEG to license MP3-related patents. With Thomson and Sisvel both owning separate patents which they claim are needed by the codec, the legal status of MP3 remains unclear.
In September 2006 German officials seized MP3 players from SanDisk's booth at the IFA show in Berlin after an Italian patents firm won an injunction against the company in a dispute over licencing rights. The injunction was later reversed by a Berlin judge ; but that reversal was in turn blocked the same day by another judge from the same court, "bringing the Patent Wild West to Germany" in the words of one commentator. .
The Fraunhofer patents expire April 2010, at which time MP3 algorithms become public domain.
Alternative technologies
Many other lossy audio codecs exist, including:
...
.
- QDesign, used in QuickTime at low bitrates;
- AMR-WB+ Enhanced Adaptive Multi Rate WideBand codec, optimized for cellular and other limited bandwidth use;
- RealAudio from RealNetworks, frequently in use for streaming on websites;
- Speex, free software and patent free codec based on CELP specifically designed for speech and VoIP.
mp3PRO, MP3, AAC, and MP2 are all members of the same technological family and depend on roughly similar psychoacoustic models. The Fraunhofer Gesellschaft owns many of the basic
patents underlying these codecs, with
Dolby Labs,
Sony,
Thomson Consumer Electronics, and
AT&T holding other key patents.
There are also some lossless audio compression methods used on the Internet. While they are not similar to MP3, they are good examples of other compression schemes available. These include:
- FLAC stands for 'Free Lossless Audio Codec'
- Monkey's Audio
- SHN, also known as Shorten
- TTA
- Wavpack
- Apple Lossless
Listening have attempted to find the best-quality lossy audio codecs at certain bitrates. At 128 kbit/s, Ogg Vorbis, AAC, MPC and WMA Pro tied for first place with LAME MP3 a little behind. At 64 kbit/s, AAC-HE and mp3pro performed marginally better than other codecs. At high bitrates , most people do not hear significant differences. What is considered 'CD quality' is quite subjective.
Though proponents of newer codecs such as WMA and RealAudio have asserted that their respective algorithms can achieve CD quality at 64 kbit/s, listening tests have shown otherwise; however, the quality of these codecs at 64 kbit/s is definitely superior to MP3 at the same bitrate. The developers of the patent-free
Ogg Vorbis codec claim that their algorithm surpasses MP3, RealAudio and WMA sound quality, and the listening tests mentioned above support that claim. Thomson claims that its mp3PRO codec achieves CD quality at 64 kbit/s, but listeners have reported that a 64 kbit/s mp3PRO file compares in quality to a 112 kbit/s MP3 file and does not come reasonably close to CD quality until about 80 kbit/s.
MP3, which was designed and tuned for use alongside MPEG-1/2 Video, generally performs poorly on monaural data at less than 48 kbit/s or in stereo at less than 80 kbit/s.
See also
External links
-
-
- at The Data Compression News Blog
-
