Counterfactual definiteness

Counterfactual definiteness

Ask a question about 'Counterfactual definiteness'
Start a new discussion about 'Counterfactual definiteness'
Answer questions from other users
Full Discussion Forum
In some interpretations of quantum mechanics
Quantum mechanics
Quantum mechanics, also known as quantum physics or quantum theory, is a branch of physics providing a mathematical description of much of the dual particle-like and wave-like behavior and interactions of energy and matter. It departs from classical mechanics primarily at the atomic and subatomic...

, counterfactual definiteness (CFD) is the ability to speak with meaning of the definiteness of the results of measurements that have not been performed (i.e. the ability to assume the existence of objects, and properties of objects, even when they have not been measured). A macroscopic example of CFD would be the assumption -without measurement- that a ball, thrown into the air, will return to the Earth due to gravity. CFD says that if a phenomenon (the return of an airborne ball to the Earth) has been reproducibly measured in the past, one can safely assume its presence in the future without having to refer to additional measurement events for proof of its existence. More rigorously, an interpretation of quantum mechanics satisfies CFD if it includes in the statistical population
Statistical population
A statistical population is a set of entities concerning which statistical inferences are to be drawn, often based on a random sample taken from the population. For example, if we were interested in generalizations about crows, then we would describe the set of crows that is of interest...

 of measurement results, those measurements which are counter-factual by virtue of their being excluded by the quantum mechanical prohibition on simultaneous measurement of certain pairs of properties.

For example, the Heisenberg uncertainty principle
Uncertainty principle
In quantum mechanics, the Heisenberg uncertainty principle states a fundamental limit on the accuracy with which certain pairs of physical properties of a particle, such as position and momentum, can be simultaneously known...

 states that you cannot simultaneously know both the position and momentum
In classical mechanics, linear momentum or translational momentum is the product of the mass and velocity of an object...

 of a particle. Suppose one measures the position: this act destroys any information about its momentum. Is it then possible to talk about the outcome one would have obtained if one had measured its momentum instead of its position? In terms of mathematical formalism, is such a counterfactual momentum measurement to be included, together with the factual position measurement, in the statistical population of possible outcomes describing the particle? If the position was found to be r0 then in an interpretation satisfying CFD, the statistical population describing position and momentum would contain all pairs (r0,p) for every possible momentum value p, whereas an interpretation that rejects counterfactual values completely would only have the pair (r0,⊥) where ⊥ denotes an undefined value. To use a macroscopic analogy, an interpretation which rejects CFD views measuring the position as akin to asking where in a room a person is standing, while measuring the momentum is akin to asking if the person's lap is empty or has something on it. If the person has been made to stand then that person has no lap and neither of the statements "the person's lap is empty" and "there is something on the person's lap" is true. Any statistical calculation based on values where the person is standing at some place in the room and simultaneously has a lap as if sitting would be meaningless.

Counterfactual definiteness is a basic assumption, which, together with locality, leads to Bell inequalities. In their derivation it is explicitly assumed that every possible measurement, even if not performed, can be included in statistical calculations. The calculation involves averaging over sets of outcomes which cannot all be simultaneously factual - if some are assumed to be factual outcomes of an experiment others have to be assumed counterfactual. (Which ones are designated as factual is not important: the point is that they cannot all be designated factual simultaneously.) Bell's Theorem
Bell's theorem
In theoretical physics, Bell's theorem is a no-go theorem, loosely stating that:The theorem has great importance for physics and the philosophy of science, as it implies that quantum physics must necessarily violate either the principle of locality or counterfactual definiteness...

 actually proves that every type of quantum theory must necessarily violate either locality or CFD.

CFD is present in any interpretation of quantum mechanics that regards quantum mechanical measurements to be objective descriptions of a system's state independent of the measuring process. It is not present in interpretations such as the Copenhagen interpretation
Copenhagen interpretation
The Copenhagen interpretation is one of the earliest and most commonly taught interpretations of quantum mechanics. It holds that quantum mechanics does not yield a description of an objective reality but deals only with probabilities of observing, or measuring, various aspects of energy quanta,...

 and its modern refinements, which regard the measured values as resulting from both the system being measured and the measuring apparatus, and regard the system as being indefinable in the absence of an interaction between the two. To give a macroscopic analogy using the idea of a laptop screen: The former type of interpretation sees quantum mechanical measurements as akin to measuring say the diagonal length of a laptop screen - this quantity is well defined regardless of whether one holds a ruler across the screen or not. The latter type of interpretation that rejects CFD sees quantum mechanical measurements as akin to asking how much your finger is warping the screen at the point where it is poking it - a question which is meaningless unless your finger is actually poking the screen.

See also

  • Determinism
    Determinism is the general philosophical thesis that states that for everything that happens there are conditions such that, given them, nothing else could happen. There are many versions of this thesis. Each of them rests upon various alleged connections, and interdependencies of things and...

  • Quantum indeterminacy
    Quantum indeterminacy
    Quantum indeterminacy is the apparent necessary incompleteness in the description of a physical system, that has become one of the characteristics of the standard description of quantum physics...

  • Elitzur–Vaidman bomb-tester
  • Renninger negative-result experiment
    Renninger negative-result experiment
    In quantum mechanics, the Renninger negative-result experiment is a thought experiment that illustrates some of the difficulties of understanding the nature of wave function collapse and measurement in quantum mechanics...

External links