Click consonant

{{Manner of articulation}} '''Clicks''' are speech sounds found as [[consonants]] in many languages of southern Africa, and in three languages of East Africa. Examples of these sounds familiar to English speakers are the [[dental click|''tsk! tsk!'']] (American spelling) or ''tut-tut'' (British spelling) used to express disapproval or pity, the [[lateral click|''tchick!'']] used to spur on a horse, and the [[alveolar click|''clip-clop!'']] sound children make to imitate a horse trotting. Technically, clicks are [[obstruent]]s articulated with two closures (points of contact) in the mouth, one forward and one at the back. The pocket of air enclosed between is [[rarefaction|rarefied]] by a sucking action of the tongue (i.e. clicks have a [[Airstream mechanism|lingual ingressive airstream mechanism]]). The forward closure is then released, producing what may be the loudest consonants in the language, although in some languages such as [[Hadza language|Hadza]] and [[Sandawe language|Sandawe]], clicks can be more subtle and may even be mistaken for [[ejective consonant|ejective stops]]. ==What clicks sound like== {{IPA chart non-pulmonic consonants with audio}} There are five places of articulation at which click consonants occur. In IPA, a click is symbolized by placing the assigned symbol for the place of click articulation adjacent to a symbol for a nonclick sound at the rear place of articulation. The IPA symbols are used in writing most Khoisan languages, but Bantu languages such as Zulu typically use Latin c, x and q for dental, lateral, and alveolar clicks respectively. * The easiest clicks for English speakers are the [[dental click]]s written with a single pipe, {{IPA|ǀ}}. They are all sharp (high-pitched) squeaky sounds made by sucking on the front teeth. A simple dental click is used in English to express pity or to shame someone, and sometimes to call an animal, and is written ''tsk!'' in American English, or ''tut-tut!'' in British English. * Next most familiar to English speakers are the [[lateral click]]s written with a double pipe, {{IPA|ǁ}}. They are also squeaky sounds, though less sharp than {{IPA|ǀ}}, made by sucking on the molars on either side (or both sides) of the mouth. A simple lateral click is made in English to get a horse moving, and is conventionally written ''tchick!'' * Then there are the [[bilabial click]]s, written with a bull's eye, {{IPA|ʘ}}. These are lip-smacking sounds, but without the pursing of the lips found in a kiss. The above clicks sound like [[affricate]]s, in that they involve a lot of friction. The other two families are more abrupt sounds that do not have this friction. * With the [[alveolar click]]s, written with an exclamation mark, {{IPA|ǃ}}, the tip of the tongue is pulled down abruptly and forcefully from the roof of the mouth, sometimes using a lot of jaw motion, and making a hollow ''pop!'' like a cork being pulled from an empty bottle. These sounds can be quite loud. * Finally, the [[palatal click]]s, {{IPA|ǂ}}, are made with a flat tongue, and are softer popping sounds than the {{IPA|ǃ}} clicks. ==Languages with clicks== Clicks occur in all three [[Khoisan languages|Khoisan language families]] of southern Africa, where they may be the most numerous consonants. To a lesser extent they are found in two groups of neighbouring [[Bantu languages]] which [[Sprachbund|borrowed them]], directly or indirectly, from Khoisan. In the southeast, in eastern [[South Africa]], [[Swaziland]], [[Lesotho]], [[Zimbabwe]], and southern [[Mozambique]], they were adopted from a [[Tuu languages|Tuu language]] or languages by the languages of the Nguni cluster (especially [[Zulu language|Zulu]], [[Xhosa language|Xhosa]], and [[Phuthi language|Phuthi]], but also to a lesser extent [[Swati language|Swazi]] and [[Ndebele language|Ndebele]]), and spread from them in a reduced fashion to the Zulu-based [[pidgin]] [[Fanagalo]], [[Sesotho language|Sesotho]], [[Tsonga language|Tsonga]], [[Ronga language|Ronga]], [[Tumbuka language|Tumbuka]], and more recently to [[Ndau language|Ndau]] and urban varieties of [[Pedi language|Pedi]], where the spread of clicks is an ongoing process. The second point of transfer was near the [[Caprivi Strip]] and the [[Okavango River]], where it was apparently the [[Yeyi language]] which borrowed the clicks from a [[Khoe languages|West Kalihari Khoe language]], and which in turn passed on a reduced click inventory to the neighboring [[Mbukushu language|Mbukushu]], [[Kwangali language|Kwangali]], [[Gciriku language|Gciriku]], [[Kuhane language|Kuhane]], and [[Fwe language|Fwe]] languages in [[Angola]], [[Namibia]], [[Botswana]], and [[Zambia]]. There are three minority languages in East Africa which use clicks: [[Sandawe language|Sandawe]] and [[Hadza language|Hadza]] of [[Tanzania]], as well as [[Dahalo language|Dahalo]], an endangered South [[Cushitic languages|Cushitic language]] of [[Kenya]] which has clicks in only a few dozen words. It is thought these may remain from an episode of [[language shift]]. The only non-African language known to employ clicks as regular speech sounds is [[Damin]], a ritual code used by speakers of [[Lardil]] in [[Australia]]. One of the clicks in Damin is actually an ''egressive'' click, using the tongue to compress the air in the mouth for an outward (egressive) "spurt". The Southern African Khoisan languages only utilize [[root word|root]]-initial clicks. [[Hadza language|Hadza]], [[Sandawe language|Sandawe]], and several of the [[Bantu languages]] also allow [[syllable]]-initial clicks within roots, but in no known language does a click close a syllable or end a word. English and many other languages may use clicks in [[interjection]]s, such as the dental "tsk-tsk" sound used to express disapproval, or the lateral ''tchick'' used with horses. In [[Ningdu]] Chinese, flapped nasal clicks are used in nursery rhymes. In [[Persian language|Persian]], [[Greek language|Greek]], [[Maltese language|Maltese]], [[Turkic language|Turkic]] and [[Levantine Arabic]] as well as southern Italian dialects such as Sicilian, a click accompanied by tipping the head upwards signifies "no". Clicks occasionally turn up elsewhere, as in the special [[register (linguistics)|register]]s twins sometimes develop with each other, and in onomatopoeic usages. In West Africa, clicks have been reported allophonically, and similarly in German, faint clicks have been recorded in rapid speech where the consonants {{IPA|/t/}} and {{IPA|/k/}} overlap between words. The fictional native language of the [[Tenctonese]] in the film and television series ''[[Alien Nation]]'' incorporates some soft click consonants. ==The airstream== The essence of a click is a lingual ingressive airstream mechanism. However, in nasal clicks the nasalization involves a separate nasal airstream, generally [[pulmonic egressive]] but occasionally [[pulmonic ingressive]]. Similarly, voiced clicks also require a simultaneous pulmonic egressive airstream to power the voiced [[phonation]]. The front articulation may be [[Coronal consonant|coronal]] or, rarely, [[Labial consonant|labial]]. The front and rear articulations are interdependent, with the rear contact being [[uvular consonant|uvular]] or [[pharyngeal consonant|pharyngeal]] depending on the shape of the front of the tongue. The rear articulation had been thought to be [[Velar consonant|velar]], with a few languages contrasting a uvular place of articulation. However, recent investigations of languages with very complex click systems such as [[Nǁng language|Nǁng]] have revealed that the supposed velar–uvular contrast is actually a contrast of a simple clicks versus click–plosive [[contour (linguistics)|airstream contours]] or [[consonant clusters]]. Even in languages without such a distinction, such as [[Xhosa language|Xhosa]], experiments have shown that when the click release is removed from a recording, the resulting sound is judged to be uvular, not velar. Therefore, although not all languages have been investigated on this point, phoneticians have recently come to use the term ''lingual'' (made with the tongue) as being more accurate for this airstream mechanism than ''velaric'' (made with the velum). ==Types of clicks== As noted above, clicks necessarily involve at least two closures: an anterior articulation which has traditionally been represented by the special click symbol in the IPA, and a posterior articulation which has been traditionally described as oral or [[nasal consonant|nasal]], voiced or voiceless, etc. The literature also describes a contrast between [[velar consonant|velar]] and [[uvular consonant|uvular]] rear articulations for some languages. However, recent work has shown that for languages which make this distinction, all clicks have a uvular, or even pharyngeal, rear closure, and that the clicks explicitly described as uvular are in fact clusters/contours of a click plus a pulmonic consonant, in which the clusters/contour has two release bursts, the click itself and then a uvular consonant. In the case of "velar" clicks in these languages, on the other hand, there is only a single release burst, that of the forward click release, and the release of the rear articulation isn't audible.{{Citation needed|date=May 2008}} Nonetheless, in most of the literature the stated place of the click is the anterior articulation (called the ''release'' or ''influx),'' while the manner is ascribed to the posterior articulation (called the ''accompaniment'' or ''efflux),'' as in a "nasal dental click". There are numerous manners of clicks. These include what has been described as voiceless, voiced, aspirate, breathy voiced, nasal, voiceless nasal, breathy voiced nasal, glottalized, voiceless nasal glottalized, affricate, ejective affricate, prevoiced, prenasalized. In a few of the Khoisan languages, clicks cluster with other obstruents. Examples of such clusters in ǃXóõ a voiced velar click followed by voiceless affricated ejective, {{IPA|[ɡǃkxʼ]}}, and a velar ejective click followed by uvular ejective, {{IPA|[kǃʼqʼ]}}. The size of click inventories ranges from as few as three (in [[Sesotho_phonology#Consonants|Sesotho]]) or four (in [[Dahalo language|Dahalo]]), to dozens in the [[Kx'a languages|Kx'a]] and [[Tuu languages]] (Northern and Southern Khoisan). [[Taa language|ǃXoon]], a Tuu language, has fifty click phonemes and over 70% of words in the dictionary of this language begin with a click. Clicks appear more [[stop consonant|stop]]-like or more [[affricate]]-like depending on their place of articulation: In southern Africa, clicks involving an [[apical consonant|apical]] [[alveolar consonant|alveolar]] or [[laminal consonant|laminal]] [[postalveolar consonant|postalveolar]] closure are acoustically abrupt and sharp, like stops, while [[labial consonant|bilabial]], [[dental consonant|dental]], and [[lateral consonant|lateral]] clicks typically have longer and acoustically noisier releases that are more like affricates. In East Africa, however, the alveolar clicks tend to be [[flap consonant|flapped]], while the lateral clicks tend to be more sharp and abrupt. ==Transcription== The five click releases with dedicated symbols in the [[International Phonetic Alphabet]] (IPA) are [[bilabial click|bilabial]] {{IPA|ʘ}}, [[dental click|dental]] {{IPA|ǀ}}, [[palatal click|palato-alveolar]] or "palatal" {{IPA|ǂ}}, [[postalveolar click|(post)alveolar]] or "retroflex" {{IPA|ǃ}}, and [[alveolar lateral click|alveolar lateral]] {{IPA|ǁ}}. In most languages, the retroflex and palatal releases are "abrupt"; that is, they are sharp popping sounds with little frication (turbulent airflow). The bilabial, dental, and lateral releases, on the other hand, are typically "noisy": they are longer, lip- or tooth-sucking sounds with turbulent airflow, and are sometimes called affricates. (This applies to the forward articulation; both may also have either an affricate or non-affricate rear articulation as well.) The [[apical consonant|apical]] releases, {{IPA|ǃ}} and {{IPA|ǁ}}, are sometimes called "grave", because their pitch is dominated by low frequencies; while the [[laminal consonant|laminal]] releases, {{IPA|ǀ}} and {{IPA|ǂ}}, are sometimes called "acute", because they are dominated by high frequencies. (At least in the [[Nǁng language]] and [[Juǀʼhoan language|Juǀʼhoan]], this is associated with a difference in the placement of the rear articulation: "grave" clicks are [[uvular consonant|uvular]], whereas "acute" clicks are [[pharyngeal consonant|pharyngeal]].) Thus the alveolar click {{IPA|/ǃ/}} sounds something like a cork pulled from a bottle (a low-pitch pop), at least in Xhosa; while the dental click {{IPA|/ǀ/}} is like English ''tsk! tsk!,'' a high-pitched sucking on the incisors. The lateral clicks are pronounced by sucking on the molars of one or both sides. The bilabial click {{IPA|/ʘ/}} is different from what many people associate with a kiss: the lips are pressed more-or-less flat together, as they are for a {{IPA|[p]}} or an {{IPA|[m]}}, not rounded as they are for a {{IPA|[w]}}. The most populous languages with clicks, Zulu and Xhosa, use the letters ''c, q, x,'' by themselves and in [[digraph (orthography)|digraphs]], to write click consonants. Most Khoisan languages, on the other hand (with the notable exceptions of [[Naro language|Naro]] and [[Sandawe language|Sandawe]]), use a more iconic system based on the [[Vertical bar|pipe]] ‹|›. (The exclamation point for the "retroflex" click was originally a pipe with a subscript dot, along the lines of ''ṭ, ḍ, ṇ'' used to transcribe the retroflex consonants of India.) {| class=wikitable |+ Competing orthographies !rowspan=2| !!rowspan=2|bilabial!!colspan=2|laminal!!colspan=2|apical |- !dental!!palatal!!alveolar!!lateral |- align=center ! Khoisanist |{{IPA|ʘ}}||{{IPA|ǀ}}||{{IPA|ǂ}}||{{IPA|ǃ}}||{{IPA|ǁ}} |- align=center ! old IPA |{{IPA|}}||{{IPA|ʇ}}||{{IPA|°}}||{{IPA|ʗ}}||{{IPA|ʖ}} |- align=center ! Bantu | ||{{IPA|c}}|| {{IPA|(ç tc qc)}}{{ref|pal}} ||{{IPA|q}}||{{IPA|x}} |} {{note|pal}} The bilabial and palatal clicks do not occur in written Bantu languages. However, the palatal clicks have been romanized in Naron, [[Juǀʼhoan language|Juǀʼhõasi]], and !Xung, where have been transcribed ''tc, ç,'' and ''qc'', respectively. There are a few less well attested articulations, such as a noisy laminal denti-alveolar lateral release ({{IPA|‹Ⅲ›}} [triple pipe] in an ''ad hoc'' transcription), which contrasts with an apical postalveolar lateral in Mangetti Dune ǃKung; an abrupt sub-apical retroflex release {{IPA|‹‼›}} in Angolan ǃKung; and a "slapped" alveolar click {{IPA|‹ǃ¡›}} in Hadza and Sandawe, where the tongue slaps the bottom of the mouth after the release. (These distinctions may suffice for the Damin releases as well.) However, the Khoisan languages are poorly attested, and it is quite possible that, as they become better described, more click releases will be found. In the literature, the places not directly supported by the IPA are transcribed with ''ad hoc'' digraphs: {| class=wikitable |+Provisional extended click symbols ! !!bilabial!!dental!!alveolar!!retroflex!!palatal |- align=center !Central |{{IPA|ʘ}}||{{IPA|ǀ}}||{{IPA|ǃ}}||{{IPA|‼}}||{{IPA|ǂ}} |- align=center !Lateral | bgcolor=#f2f2f2| ||{{IPA|ǀǀǀ}}||{{IPA|ǁ}}|| |- align=center !Flapped | || ||{{IPA|ǃ¡}}|| || |} Formerly when a click consonant was transcribed, two symbols were used, one for each articulation, and connected with a tie bar. This is because a click such as {{IPA|[ŋ͡ǂ]}} was analyzed as a nasal velar rear articulation {{IPA|[ŋ]}} pronounced simultaneously with the forward ingressive release {{IPA|[ǂ]}}. The symbols may be written in either order, depending on the analysis: {{IPA|‹ŋ͡ǂ›}} or {{IPA|‹ǂ͡ŋ›}}. However, a tie bar was not often used in practice, and when the manner is [[tenuis consonant|tenuis]] (a simple {{IPA|[k]}}), it was often omitted as well. That is, {{IPA|‹ǂ›}} = {{IPA|‹kǂ›}} = {{IPA|‹ǂk›}} = {{IPA|‹k͡ǂ›}} = {{IPA|‹ǂ͡k›}}. Regardless, elements which do not overlap with the release are always written according to their temporal order: Prenasalization is always written first in {{IPA|‹ŋɡ͡ǂ›}} = {{IPA|‹ŋǂ͡ɡ›}} = {{IPA|‹ŋǂ̬›}}, and the second ejective is always written second in {{IPA|‹k͡ǂʼqʼ›}} = {{IPA|‹ǂ͡kʼqʼ›}} = {{IPA|‹ǂ͡qʼ›}}. However, it has become standard to analyze clicks as simplex segments, as research has shown that the front and rear articulations are not independent, and to use click symbols to cover the rear articulation as well, with diacritics rather than digraphs for the accompaniments. At first this tended to be {{IPA|‹ǂ, ᶢǂ, ᵑǂ›}} for {{IPA|‹k͡ǂ, ɡ͡ǂ, ŋ͡ǂ›}}, based on the belief that the rear articulation was velar; but as it has become clear that the rear articulation of both "velar" and "uvular" clicks is actually uvular or even pharyngeal, voicing and nasalization diacritics more in keeping with the IPA have started to appear: {{IPA|‹ǂ, ǂ̬, ǂ̃, ŋǂ̬›}} for {{IPA|‹ǂ, ᶢǂ, ᵑǂ, ŋᶢǂ›}}. {| class="wikitable IPA" |+Evolution of accompaniment transcription |- ! !! Tenuis !! Aspirated !! Voiced !! Nasalized !! "Uvular" |- ! Coarticulation
analysis | k͡ǂ ~ ǂ͡k
(kǂ ~ ǂk)
or ǂ || k͡ǂʰ ~ ǂ͡kʰ
(kǂʰ ~ ǂkʰ) || ɡ͡ǂ ~ ǂ͡ɡ
(ɡǂ ~ ǂɡ) || ŋ͡ǂ ~ ǂ͡ŋ
(ŋǂ ~ ǂŋ) || q͡ǂ ~ ǂ͡q
(qǂ ~ ǂq) |- ! Unified, velar | ǂ || ǂʰ || ᶢǂ || ᵑǂ || ^qǂ |- ! Full IPA | ǂ || ǂʰ || ǂ̬ || ǂ̃ || ǂ͡q |} In practical orthography, the voicing or nasalization is sometimes given the anterior place of articulation: ''dc'' for {{IPA|ᶢǀ}} and ''mʘ'' for {{IPA|ᵑʘ}}, for example. While the [[SAMPA]] encoding for IPA into [[ASCII]] doesn't have symbols for transcribing clicks, the proposed [[X-SAMPA]] standard does: O\, |\, |\|\, =\, and !. Some instead suggest ||\, #\ or "\ for the alveolar lateral click. The [[Kirshenbaum]] system uses a different method: clicks are denoted by digraphs, with the click symbol (always "!") added to the stop homorganic to the release, but with the manner of the accompaniment. For example, /t!/ is a voiceless dental click, and /m!/ is a nasal bilabial click. This transcription is used in the literature on Damin. ==Places of articulation== These are often called click ''types, releases,'' or ''influxes.'' There are seven or eight known releases, not counting slapped or egressive clicks. These are ''bilabial affricated'' {{IPA|ʘ}}, or "bilabial"; ''laminal denti-alveolar affricated'' {{IPA|ǀ}}, or "dental"; ''apical (post)alveolar plosive'' {{IPA|ǃ}}, or "alveolar"; ''laminal postalveolar (palato-alveolar) plosive'' {{IPA|ǂ}}, or "palatal"; ''subapical postalveolar ([[Retroflex click|retroflex]])'' {{IPA|ǃ˞}} (in central Ju, generally written {{unicode|‼}}); and two lateral clicks, which in the only dialects known to distinguish them (northern Ju) are ''[[Dental lateral click|laminal denti-alveolar lateral]]'' {{IPA|ǁ̻}} with a forward release, and ''apical postalveolar lateral'' {{IPA|ǁ̺}} with a rear release. There is an additional [[fricated alveolar click]] (a historically palatal click with an s-like release), provisionally transcribed {{IPA|ǃ͡s}}, in [[Ekoka !Xung]]. Given the poor state of documentation of Khoisan languages, it is quite possible that additional releases will turn up. However, no language is known to contrast more than five places of articulation. {| class=wikitable ! Click release
inventory !! Languages !! Notes |- | dental {{IPA|ǀ}} only || Dahalo || Various nasal clicks only. |- | variable {{IPA|ǀ ~ ǃ ~ ǁ}} || Sotho, Gciriku, Mbukushu || In Sotho the clicks tend to be alveolar, in Gciriku and Mbukushu dental. |- | 2 releases, {{IPA|ǀ}}, {{IPA|ǂ}} || Kwadi || {{IPA|ǂ}} not found with all manners |- | 3 releases, {{IPA|ǀ}}, {{IPA|ǃ}}, {{IPA|ǁ}} || Sandawe, Hadza, Xhosa, Zulu || In Hadza and sometimes in Sandawe, {{IPA|ǃ}} is "slapped". |- | 4 releases, {{IPA|ǀ}}, {{IPA|ǂ}}, {{IPA|ǃ}}, {{IPA|ǁ}} || Korana, Nama, Yeyi, Zhuǀ'hõasi (southeastern Ju) |- | 4 releases, {{IPA|ǀ}}, {{IPA|ǂ}}, {{IPA|ǃ˞}}, {{IPA|ǁ}} || ǃKung (Grootfontein) |- | 5 releases, {{IPA|ʘ}}, {{IPA|ǀ}}, {{IPA|ǂ}}, {{IPA|ǃ}}, {{IPA|ǁ}} || ǂHõã, Nǀu, ǀXam, ǃXóõ |- | 5 releases, {{IPA|ǀ}}, {{IPA|ǂ}}, {{IPA|ǃ}}, {{IPA|ǁ̺}}, {{IPA|ǁ̪}} || ǃKung (Angola) |- | 5 releases, {{IPA|ʘ}}, {{IPA|ʘ↑}}, {{IPA|ǀ}}, {{IPA|ǃ}}, {{IPA|ǃ˞}} || Damin || Nasal clicks only. |- | 6 releases, {{IPA|ʘ}}, {{IPA|ǀ}}, {{IPA|ǂ}}, {{IPA|ǃ}}, {{IPA|ǁ̺}}, {{IPA|ǁ̪}} || Proto-Kw'a || (reconstructed) |} Extra-linguistically, [[Coatlán Zapotec]] of [[Mexico]] uses a [[linguolabial]] click, {{IPA|[ǀ̼ʔ]}}, as mimesis for a pig drinking water. ===Names found in the literature=== The terms for the click releases were originally developed by Bleek in 1911. Since then there has been some conflicting variation. Here are the terms used in some of the main references. {| | '''Click release''' || '''Bantu letters''' || '''Also known as:''' || |- | {{IPA|ǀ}} dental || ''c'' || dental affricative/affricated/with friction; alveolar affricated; denti-alveolar; apico-lamino-dental; denti-pharyngeal |- | {{IPA|ǂ}} palatal || || palato-alveolar; alveolar; alveolar instantaneous; denti-alveolar implosive; palato-pharyngeal |- | {{IPA|ǃ}} alveolar || ''q'' || cerebral; (post-) alveolar implosive; palato-alveolar; palato-alveolar instantaneous; palatal; palatal retroflex; apico-palatal; central alveo-uvular |- | {{IPA|ǁ}} lateral || ''x'' || lateral affricative/with friction; alveolar lateral affricated; post-alveolar lateral; lateral apico-alveo-palatal; lateral alveo-uvular |} ==The back-vowel constraint== [[Image:Clicks and the BVC.svg|thumb|The shape of the tongue in Nama when articulating an alveolar click (blue) and a palatal click (red) [throat to the right]. The articulation of the vowel [i] is slightly forward of the red line, with its peak coinciding with the dip of the blue line.]]In several languages, including Nama and Ju|’hoansi, the alveolar and lateral clicks only occur, or preferentially occur, before [[back vowel]]s, while the dental and palatal clicks may occur before any vowel. The effect is most noticeable with the high front vowel {{IPA|[i]}}. In Nama, for example, the diphthong {{IPA|[əi]}} is common but {{IPA|[i]}} is rare after alveolar clicks, whereas the opposite is true after dental and palatal clicks. This is a common effect of [[uvular consonant|uvular]] or uvularized consonants on vowels in both click and non-click languages. In [[Taa language|Taa]], for example, the back-vowel constraint is triggered by both alveolar clicks and uvular stops, but not by palatal clicks or velar stops: sequences such as {{IPA|*/ǃi/}} and {{IPA|*/qi/}} are rare to non-existent, whereas sequences such as {{IPA|/ǂi/}} and {{IPA|/ki/}} are common. Miller ''et al.'' (2003) used [[ultrasound imaging]] to show that the rear articulation of the alveolar clicks ({{IPA|[ǃ]}}) in Nama is substantially different that that of palatal and dental clicks. Specifically, the shape of the body of the tongue in palatal clicks is very similar to that of the vowel {{IPA|[i]}}, and involves the same tongue muscles, so that sequences such as {{IPA|[ǂi]}} involved a simple and quick transition. The rear articulation of the alveolar clicks, however, is several centimeters further back, and involves a different set of muscles in the uvular region. The part of the tongue required to approach the palate for the vowel {{IPA|[i]}} is deeply retracted in {{IPA|[ǃ]}}, as it lies at the bottom of the air pocket used to create the vacuum required for click airstream. This makes the transition required for {{IPA|[ǃi]}} much more complex and the timing more difficult than the shallower and more forward tongue position of the palatal clicks. Consequently, {{IPA|[ǃi]}} takes 50 [[millisecond|ms]] longer to pronounce than {{IPA|[ǂi]}}, the same amount of time required to pronounce {{IPA|[ǃəi]}}. ==Manners of articulation== ''(Data is primarily from Ladefoged; see references at individual language articles.)'' Click manners are often called click ''accompaniments'' or ''effluxes,'' but both terms have met with objections on theoretical grounds. There is a great variety of click manners, both simplex and complex, the latter variously analysed as consonant [[consonant cluster|clusters]] or [[contour (linguistics)|contour]]s. With so few click languages, and so little study of them, it is also unclear to what extent clicks in different languages are equivalent. For example, the {{IPA|[ǃkˀ]}} of Nama, {{IPA|[ǃkˀ ~ ŋˀǃk]}} of Sandawe, and {{IPA|[ŋ̊ǃˀ ~ ŋǃkˀ]}} of Hadza may be essentially the same phone, as may {{IPA|[ǃk͡xʼ]}} and {{IPA|[ǃq͡χʼ]}}; no one language distinguishes either set, and the differences in transcription may have more to do with the approach of the linguist than with actual differences in the sounds. Such suspected allophones/allographs are listed on a common row in the table below. Some Khoisan languages are [[Linguistic typology|typologically]] unusual in allowing mixed [[phonation|voicing]] in non-click consonant clusters/contours, such as {{IPA|dt͡sʼk͡xʼ}}, so it is not surprising that they would allow mixed voicing in clicks as well. This may be an effect of epiglottalized voiced consonants, since voicing is incompatible with epiglottalization. There is ongoing discussion as to which clicks are best analysed as consonant clusters. For example, some linguists feel that ejective clicks are not possible, and indeed in many Khoisan languages they appear to be clusters. However, in other languages, phonetic measurements have found that, although the ejective release follows the click release, it is the rear closure of the click that is ejective, not a subsequent consonant. This is one reason for analysing such clicks as airstream contours rather than clusters. Of the languages illustrated below, *[[ǃXoon language|ǃXoon]] and [[Nǁng language|Nǁng]] are [[Tuu languages]] *[[ǂHoan language|ǂHoan]] and [[Juǀʼhoan language|Juǀʼhõasi]] are [[Kx'a languages]] *[[Korana language|Korana]] and [[Gǀwi language|Gǀui]] are [[Khoe languages]] (all spoken primarily in [[Namibia]] and [[Botswana]]; [[Nama language|Nama]] is like Korana except it has lost {{IPA|[ǃk͡xʼ]}}) *[[Sandawe language|Sandawe]] and [[Hadza language|Hadza]] are [[language isolate]]s spoken in [[Tanzania]] *[[Dahalo language|Dahalo]] is a [[Cushitic languages|Cushitic]] language of [[Kenya]] *[[Xhosa language|Xhosa]] and [[Yeyi language|Yeyi]] are [[Bantu languages]] *[[Damin]] was an initiation jargon in northern [[Australia]]. The four Dahalo manners occur only with a dental release. Damin has only nasal clicks, but in addition has an oral "spurt" that might be considered an egressive click. Yeyi also has prenasalized versions (not shown) of at least some of its clicks, which are analyzed as consonant clusters. Dahalo has labialized clicks. {| class=wikitable ! '''Manner''' || '''ǃXóõ''' || '''Nǁng''' || '''ǂHoan''' || '''Juǀ’hõa''' || '''Korana''' || '''Gǀui''' || '''Sandawe''' || '''Hadza''' || '''Dahalo''' || '''Xhosa''' || '''Yeyi''' || '''Damin''' |- | ''[[Tenuis consonant|Tenuis]] || bgcolor="#f0c0c0" align=center | {{IPA|[ǃ]}}* || bgcolor="#f0c0c0" align=center | {{IPA|[ǃ]}}* || bgcolor="#f0c0c0" align=center | {{IPA|[ǃ]}} || bgcolor="#f0c0c0" align=center | {{IPA|[ǃ]}} || bgcolor="#f0c0c0" align=center | {{IPA|[ǃ]}} || bgcolor="#f0c0c0" align=center | {{IPA|[ǃ]}} || bgcolor="#f0c0c0" align=center | {{IPA|[ǃ]}} || bgcolor="#f0c0c0" align=center | {{IPA|[ǃ]}} || || bgcolor="#f0c0c0" align=center | {{IPA|[ǃ]}} || bgcolor="#f0c0c0" align=center | {{IPA|[ǃ]}} || |- | ''Aspirated || bgcolor="#f0c0c0" align=center | {{IPA|[ǃʰ]}}* || bgcolor="#f0c0c0" align=center | {{IPA|[ǃʰ]}}* || bgcolor="#f0c0c0" align=center | {{IPA|[ǃʰ]}} || bgcolor="#f0c0c0" align=center | {{IPA|[ǃʰ]}} || bgcolor="#f0c0c0" align=center | {{IPA|[ǃʰ]}} || bgcolor="#f0c0c0" align=center | {{IPA|[ǃʰ]}} || bgcolor="#f0c0c0" align=center | {{IPA|[ǃʰ]}} || bgcolor="#f0c0c0" align=center | {{IPA|[ǃʰ]}} || || bgcolor="#f0c0c0" align=center | {{IPA|[ǃʰ]}} || bgcolor="#f0c0c0" align=center | {{IPA|[ǃʰ ~ ǃx]}} || |- | ''Glottalized
(often prenasalized between vowels) || bgcolor="#f0c0c0" align=center | {{IPA|[ǃˀ]}}* || bgcolor="#f0c0c0" align=center | {{IPA|[ᵑ̊ǃˀ]}}* || bgcolor="#f0c0c0" align=center | {{IPA|[ǃˀ]
([ŋˀǃ])}} || bgcolor="#f0c0c0" align=center | {{IPA|[ǃˀ]}}
({{IPA|[ᵑ̊ǃˀ]}}?) || bgcolor="#f0c0c0" align=center | {{IPA|[ᵑǃˀ]}} || bgcolor="#f0c0c0" align=center | {{IPA|[ǃˀ]
([ŋˀǃ])}} || bgcolor="#f0c0c0" align=center | {{IPA|[ǃˀ]
([ŋˀǃ])}} || bgcolor="#f0c0c0" align=center | {{IPA|[ǃˀ]
([ŋˀǃ])}} || bgcolor="#f0c0c0" align=center | {{IPA|[ᵑ̊ǃ]}} || bgcolor="#f0c0c0" align=center | {{IPA|[ᵑ̊ǃˀ]}} || bgcolor="#f0c0c0" align=center | {{IPA|[ᵑǃˀ]}} || |- | ''Voiced || bgcolor="#f0c0c0" align=center | {{IPA|[ᶢǃ]}}* || bgcolor="#f0c0c0" align=center | {{IPA|[ᶢǃ]}}* || bgcolor="#f0c0c0" align=center | {{IPA|[ᶢǃ]}} || bgcolor="#f0c0c0" align=center | {{IPA|[ᶢǃ]}} || || bgcolor="#f0c0c0" align=center | {{IPA|[ᶢǃ]}} || bgcolor="#f0c0c0" align=center | {{IPA|[ᶢǃ]}}
({{IPA|ŋᶢǃ}}) || || || || bgcolor="#f0c0c0" align=center | {{IPA|[ᶢǃ]}} || |- | ''Breathy-voiced || bgcolor="#f0c0c0" align=center | {{IPA|[ᶢǃʱ]}}* || || || bgcolor="#f0c0c0" align=center | {{IPA|[ᶢǃʱ ~ ᶢǃˠ]}} || || || || || || bgcolor="#f0c0c0" align=center | {{IPA|[ᶢǃʱ]}} || || |- | ''Nasal || bgcolor="#f0c0c0" align=center | {{IPA|[ᵑǃ]}}* || bgcolor="#f0c0c0" align=center | {{IPA|[ᵑǃ]}}* || bgcolor="#f0c0c0" align=center | {{IPA|[ᵑǃ]}} || bgcolor="#f0c0c0" align=center | {{IPA|[ᵑǃ]}} || bgcolor="#f0c0c0" align=center | {{IPA|[ᵑǃ]}} || bgcolor="#f0c0c0" align=center | {{IPA|[ᵑǃ]}} || bgcolor="#f0c0c0" align=center | {{IPA|[ᵑǃ]}} || bgcolor="#f0c0c0" align=center | {{IPA|[ᵑǃ]}} || bgcolor="#f0c0c0" align=center | {{IPA|[ᵑǃ]}} || bgcolor="#f0c0c0" align=center | {{IPA|[ᵑǃ]}} || bgcolor="#f0c0c0" align=center | {{IPA|[ᵑǃ]}} || bgcolor="#f0c0c0" align=center | {{IPA|[ᵑǃ]}} |- | ''Aspirated nasal || bgcolor="#f0c0c0" align=center | {{IPA|[ǃŋ̊]}}* || bgcolor="#f0c0c0" align=center | {{IPA|[ᵑ̊ǃʰ]}}* || bgcolor="#f0c0c0" align=center | {{IPA|[ᵑ̊ǃʰ]}} || bgcolor="#f0c0c0" align=center | {{IPA|[ᵑ̊ǃʰ]}} || bgcolor="#f0c0c0" align=center | {{IPA|[ᵑ̊ǃʰ]}} || bgcolor="#f0c0c0" align=center | {{IPA|[ᵑ̊ǃʰ]}} || || || || || || |- | ''Breathy-voiced nasal || || || || bgcolor="#f0c0c0" align=center | {{IPA|[ᵑǃʱ]}} || || || || || || bgcolor="#f0c0c0" align=center | {{IPA|[ᵑǃʱ]}} || || |- | ''Voiceless ingressive pulmonic nasal with delayed aspiration || bgcolor="#f0c0c0" align=center | {{IPA|[ŋ̊↓ǃh]}} || || || || || || || || || || || |- | ''Preglottalized nasal || bgcolor="#f0c0c0" align=center | {{IPA|[ʔᵑǃ]}}* || || bgcolor="#f0c0c0" align=center | {{IPA|[ʔᵑǃ]}} || || || || || || || || || |- | ''Tenuis uvular || bgcolor="#f0c0c0" align=center | {{IPA|[ǃq]}} || bgcolor="#f0c0c0" align=center | {{IPA|[ǃq]}} || bgcolor="#f0c0c0" align=center | {{IPA|[ǃq]}} || || || bgcolor="#f0c0c0" align=center | {{IPA|[ǃq]}} || || || || || || |- | ''Aspirated uvular || || bgcolor="#f0c0c0" align=center | {{IPA|[ǃqʰ]}} || bgcolor="#f0c0c0" align=center | {{IPA|[ǃqʰ]}} || || || bgcolor="#f0c0c0" align=center | {{IPA|[ǃqʰ]}} || || || || || || |- | ''Voiced uvular || bgcolor="#f0c0c0" align=center | {{IPA|[ᶰǃɢ ~ ǃɢ]}} || || bgcolor="#f0c0c0" align=center | {{IPA|[ᶰǃɢ]}} || || || bgcolor="#f0c0c0" align=center | {{IPA|[ᶰǃɢ]}} || || || || || || |- | ''Affricate / uvularized || bgcolor="#f0c0c0" align=center | {{IPA|[ǃk͡x]}} || bgcolor="#f0c0c0" align=center | {{IPA|[ǃq͡χ]}} || bgcolor="#f0c0c0" align=center | {{IPA|[ǃq͡χ]}} || bgcolor="#f0c0c0" align=center | {{IPA|[ǃᵡ]}} || || bgcolor="#f0c0c0" align=center | {{IPA|[ǃq͡χ]}} || || || || || || |- | ''Voiced uvularized || bgcolor="#f0c0c0" align=center | {{IPA|[⁽ᶰ⁾ǃɢˣ ~ ⁽ᶰ⁾ǃɢ^ʀ]}} || || || bgcolor="#f0c0c0" align=center | {{IPA|[ᶢǃʶ]}} || || || || || || || || |- | ''Ejective'' || bgcolor="#f0c0c0" align=center | {{IPA|[ǃqʼ]}} || || bgcolor="#f0c0c0" align=center | {{IPA|[ǃqʼ]}} || || || bgcolor="#f0c0c0" align=center | {{IPA|[ǃqʼ]}} || || || || || || |- | ''Affricated ejective / epiglottalized || bgcolor="#f0c0c0" align=center | {{IPA|[ǃkʼqʼ ~ ǃkʼk͡xʼ]}} || bgcolor="#f0c0c0" align=center | {{IPA|[ǃq͡χʼ]}} || bgcolor="#f0c0c0" align=center | {{IPA|[ǃq͡χʼ]}} || bgcolor="#f0c0c0" align=center | {{IPA|[ǃᵡ^ʜ]}} || bgcolor="#f0c0c0" align=center | {{IPA|[ǃk͡xʼ]}} || bgcolor="#f0c0c0" align=center | {{IPA|[ǃq͡χʼ]}} || || || || || bgcolor="#f0c0c0" align=center | {{IPA|[ǃk͡xʼ]}} || |- | ''Voiced and aspirated / voiced epiglottalized || bgcolor="#f0c0c0" align=center | {{IPA|[ᶢǃh]}} || || || bgcolor="#f0c0c0" align=center | {{IPA|[ᶢǃʶ^ʢ]}} || || || || || || || || |- | ''Voiced affricate || bgcolor="#f0c0c0" align=center | {{IPA|[ᶢǃk͡x]}} || || || || || || || || || || || |- | ''Creaky || bgcolor="#f0c0c0" align=center | {{IPA|[ǃɡˀ]}}* || || || || || || || || || || || |} A DoBeS (2008) study found several additional manners for ǃXóõ. However, these were reanalized as consonant clusters, leaving this most complex inventory in the table above with only nine manners of clicks (these are asterisked in the table): tenuis {{IPA|/kǂ/}}, voiced {{IPA|/ɡǂ/}}, aspirated {{IPA|/kǂʰ/}}, breathy voiced {{IPA|/ɡǂʱ/}} (which Traill had analyzed as a cluster {{IPA|/ɡǂqʰ/}}), ejective {{IPA|/kǂʼ/}}, creaky {{IPA|/ɡǂˀ/}}, nasal {{IPA|/ŋǂ/}}, a true voiceless nasal {{IPA|/ŋ̊ǂ/}}, and preglottalized nasal {{IPA|/ˀŋǂ/}} (which Traill had analyzed as a cluster {{IPA|/ˀnkǂ/}}). Those believed to be clusters are {{IPA|[qǂ] = /kǂq/, [ɢǂ] = /ɡǂq/, [kǂʰ] = /kǂqʰ/, [ɡǂh] = /ɡǂqʰ ~ ɡǂɢʱ/, [qǂʼ] = /kǂqʼ/, /ɡǂqʼ/, [kǂˣ] = /kǂx/, [ɡǂx] = /ɡǂx/, [kǂʼqʼ] = /kǂqxʼ/, [ɡǂqʼ] = /ɡǂqxʼ/, [kǂˀ] = /kǂʔ/, /ɡǂʔ ~ ŋǂʔ/, [↓ŋ̊ǂʰ] = /kǂh ~ ŋ̊ǂh/, [ɢǂh] = /ɡǂh ~ ŋǂh/}}. Similarly, Miller (2007) found six of the ten manners in Nǀu to be simple clicks, with the other four being [[contour (linguistics)|airstream contours]]. ==Click genesis and click loss== Clicks are often portrayed as a primitive or primordial feature of human language. Recent genetic studies showed that clicks, which occur in languages of genetically divergent populations (e.g. Hadza, Sandawe, Khoisan), are very likely an ancient element of human language . How clicks arose is not currently known. Some linguists{{Who|date=April 2011}} speculate that clicks were initially used for [[Avoidance speech|taboo avoidance]] and then borrowed into regular speech. (Compare [[Damin]].) Others{{Who|date=April 2011}} suggest that they developed from other [[complex consonant]]s. For example, the [[Sandawe language|Sandawe]] word for 'horn', {{IPA|[tɬana]}}, with a lateral affricate, may be a cognate with the root {{IPA|[ŋǁaː]}} found throughout the [[Khoe languages|Khoe family]], which has a lateral click. This and other words suggests that at least some Khoe clicks may have formed from consonant clusters when the first vowel of a word was lost; in this instance {{IPA|[tɬana]}} → {{IPA|[tɬna]}} → {{IPA|[ǁŋa]}} (= {{IPA|[ŋǁa]}}). On the other side of the equation, several non-endangered languages in vigorous use demonstrate click loss. For example, the [[Khoe languages|East Kalahari languages]] have lost a large percentage of their clicks, presumably due to [[Bantu languages|Bantu]] influence. As a rule, a click is replaced by a consonant with the [[manner of articulation]] of the accompaniment and the [[place of articulation]] of the forward release: alveolar click releases (the {{IPA|[ǃ]}} family) tend to mutate into a velar stop or affricate, such as {{IPA|[k], [ɡ], [ŋ], [k͡x]}}; palatal clicks ({{IPA|[ǂ]}} ''etc.'') tend to mutate into a palatal stop such as {{IPA|[c], [ɟ], [ɲ], [cʼ]}}, or a post-alveolar affricate {{IPA|[tʃ], [dʒ]}}; and dental clicks ({{IPA|[ǀ]}} ''etc.'') tend to mutate into an alveolar affricate {{IPA|[ts]}}.{{Citation needed|date=April 2011}} ==Difficulty== Clicks are often presented as difficult sounds to articulate. However, children acquire them readily; a two-year-old, for example, may be able to pronounce a lateral click {{IPA|[ǁ]}} with no problem, but still be unable to pronounce {{IPA|[s]}}. ==See also== *[[Alveolar clicks]] *[[Alveolar lateral clicks]] *[[Bilabial clicks]] *[[Dental clicks]] *[[Dental lateral clicks]] *[[Fricated alveolar clicks]] *[[Palatal clicks]] *[[Retroflex clicks]] *[[List of phonetics topics]] ==External links== * [http://homepage.ntu.edu.tw/~karchung/Phonetics%20II%20page%20four.htm Collection of click-language links and audio samples]. * [http://www.theage.com.au/articles/2003/03/18/1047749768823.html Nicholas Wade, "How an ancient click clique started our mother tongue", ''The Age'',19 March 2003.] * [http://www.ling.su.se/fon/perilus/2003_21.pdf Hartmut Traunmüller (2003) "Clicks and the idea of a human protolanguage", ''Phonum 9:'' 1 - 4 (Umeå University, Dept. of Philosophy and Linguistics)] * [http://esciencenews.com/articles/2009/07/15/classifying.clicks Classifying clicks] {{IPA navigation}} {{Use dmy dates|date=April 2011}}