Home      Discussion      Topics      Dictionary      Almanac
Signup       Login
Islam

Islam

 
Muslims claim, that the many different translations of the English Bible wil...
 
Posts  1 - 8  of  8
Islam discussion
 
mvastano6164
04/22/10
Muslims claim, that the many different translations of the English Bible will render a single text with many different words and phrases. You said this was proof the Bible is corrupted and that the Koran reads exactly the same way everywhere in the world in Arabic. My question is: Since the many English translations of the Koran also render a single text with many different words, does that prove that the Koran is corrupted?
Mike

           
 
Silent
04/23/10
replied to: mvastano6164
Replied To:   Muslims claim, that the many different translations of the English...
Hey Mike...don't mixup! ..what does 'being preserved' mean?
           
 
deexaxo24
04/23/10
replied to: mvastano6164
Replied To:   Muslims claim, that the many different translations of the English...
Just for you know, language is the basic form of some cultural. If those culture lost their language, ill make u sure that their culture will be dissapear also. Juat read ur history book n look what happen to hindi Kingdoms when they lost their letter "Pallawa" and their language "Sansekerta"
           
 
mvastano6164
04/24/10
replied to: Silent
Replied To:  Hey Mike...don't mixup! ..what does 'being preserved' mean?
Silent, Are you saying that no matter what happens the the Qur'an is somehow mystically preserved? If that is what you are saying then why do you not believe the same of the old and new testaments?
Mike
           
 
mvastano6164
04/24/10
replied to: deexaxo24
Replied To:  Just for you know, language is the basic form of some cultural. If ...
Then do you agree that the Qur'an may not be preserved?
mike
           
 
deexaxo24
04/26/10
replied to: mvastano6164
Replied To:   Muslims claim, that the many different translations of the English...
Even u all translate something into ur own language,there must be have a little bit different in meaning because every word in every culture has different mean coz ther culture
           
 
Silent
04/27/10
replied to: deexaxo24
Replied To:  Even u all translate something into ur own language,there must be h...
Mike..it's not MY claim...it's the CLAIM OF GOD who revealed the Quran to Muhammad s.a.w...I've already given you the reference from The Quran.

Surah Al-Barooj:

85:21] Bal huwa qur-anun majeedun بَلْ هُوَ قُرْآنٌ مَّجِيدٌ

Rather, this is a Glorious Qur'an,


[85:22] Fee lawhin mahfoothin فِي لَوْحٍ مَّحْفُوظٍ

(Inscribed) in a Tablet Preserved!

(Y.Ali)

This Book of Allah has been memorized by the human mind for centuies. So if a Haafiz (who has learnt The Quran by heart)...lands an un-discovered island without books , he can covey the message of God to the people, word to word...

This is indeed a miracle and has it's purpose..to keep the Muslims united, and to be an evidence to what was/is right or wrong.The Old and the New , must be compared to the Final Testaments to find the TRUTH ..as the GOD is, was , and will be the SAME GOD..who sent the other Messengers and the revelations.

What does Old or New Testaments claim about their authenticity?

What is the FORMAT of the New Testament? Is'nt it like a Book of Traditions...A story book of Jesus a.s. told by someone? When were they written? Are they not comparable to the Hadith Books....well 'Sahih' doesn't mean they are really 'Authentic'......
           
 
Explorer72
05/29/11
replied to: mvastano6164
Replied To:   Muslims claim, that the many different translations of the English...
They are both corrupted.